DVD REVIEW

The Lord of the Rings: Fellowship of the Ring

The Lord of the Rings: Fellowship of the Ring


The Movie: star rating

How do you make one of the most detailed, lengthy, and popular novels of all time into a full blown feature film while faithfully sticking to every beloved detail contained within it? The answer is, you don't. Instead, you make a film that sticks as closely to it's source material as possible while staying within the necessary boundaries of filmmaking. Peter Jackson has created the impossible dream, that dream is Fellowship of the Ring, the first film in The Lord of the Rings trilogy.

But this review isn't a rant about how wonderful the books are. Unlike some fat bastard reviewers, I'm aware that I am a FILM CRITIC not a member in the Ebert... er… Oprah Book of the Month club. Still, I love these books. It's impossible not to be influenced by them at least in some way, for better or for worst. Yet, in the end, the only important question is whether or not Lord of the Rings succeeds as a film.

Directed by Peter Jackson, Fellowship of the Ring, is the first film in a series of three, collectively entitled, Lord of the Rings. Based on a series of novels of the same name by famed fantasy author J.R.R. Tolkien, The Lord of the Rings is the story of an all powerful ring and the struggle of a noble few to breaksit and its master's dark power. If you've read the books, you know just what a simplistic and dumbed down explanation that is. Lord of the Rings is much more than a bunch of furry footed creatures and wizards running about with swords and using silly medieval catch phrases. It's a journey of spirit and darkness unlike any other. Director Peter Jackson has re-created a world so full of history, detail, and affection, that it far surpasses the work of any other. The impossible dream of Tolkien fans has come true, and the beauty, majesty, and genius of Tolkien's world is at last fully realized.

Despite being populated with wizards, elves, dwarfs, and trolls, Lord of the Rings has more in common with epic films like Ben Hur or The Ten Commandments than it does with the comparatively small-scale mild adventurism that is the likes of Harry Potter. Fellowship bites down hard and achieves a beautifully broad and dramatic scale, balancing the mind-boggling beauty of Tolkien's Middle Earth with the majesty and history of its characters.

This is a film of contrast and familiarity. Contrast it its landscapes, from the comfortable, sweetly beautiful landscapes of Hobbiton, to the dark and disturbing dangers of deeply delved Moria, to the majestic, breathtaking tree homes of Lothlorien and the elves. Familiarity in it's characters, brought together by the fickle scales of fate, desperately balancing their lives against evil for the greater good. It's also a movie about struggle and determination, as the smallest and meekest of creatures enters a world far beyond their experience.

There is more here than just good directing, more than just good story telling, more than just good filmmaking. To put it simply there is a LOVE for THIS material and a LOVE for what these people are doing. Most of this cast are virtual unknowns, yet to a man (or elf), they carry themselves, one and all, like veteran actors. There's a fire in their step, a twinkle in their eyes, and flash in those little glimpses at just the right moments. These people ARE these characters, and most of all they enjoy being them.

Sean Bean, a man whom almost no one has heard of, delivers such a mind blowing bit of acting as the tortured soldier Boromir. You FEEL his need to help his people, he oozes conflict and angst, all the while blazing false bravado and charm. Boromir COULD have come off as a turd. After all, he stoops to depths one doesn't expect from a hero. In his final moments, Bean so successfully captures the spirit of the man, a man driven by love for his people, a man beaten down by battle and struggle, that we easily identify with him and love him, mistakes and all.

Ian McKellan is the consummate thespian. Born to play Gandalf, his intensity DRIVES the film. Gandalf is the catalyst for everything. McKellan himself is magic. How can a man so old still be so spry? Like McKellan, Ian part deux, Ian Holm, puts his classical training to good use in portraying the surprisingly engaging Bilbo Baggins, the one-hundred eleven year old original owner of the Ring of power.

Of the Hobbits, I can only say this: If I walked past Elijah Wood, or Sean Astin on the street tomorrow, I'd quite likely be shocked to discover they are not in fact three feet tall. It's incomprehensible how Jackson's team could have possibly delivered such realistic effects. Wood, Astin, Boyd, and Monaghan as Frodo, Sam, Pippin, and Merry are so perfectly re-sized, that even KNOWING that Elijah Wood is in fact not three feet tall, makes it impossible to believe that these people are in fact any other size. That's not just good razzle-dazzle, that's damn fine acting as well. But beyond their diminutiveness, all the Hobbits fit so perfectly into their assigned roles, it's difficult NOT to buy into their Hobbitesc world. Wood in particular, manages to capture the quiet strength of Frodo, while playing off the determined tenacity of Sean Astin's Sam.

But for the ladies, it's Orlando Bloom's arrow slinging elf that steals the show. Poised, graceful, and powerful, Legolas (Bloom) dances through battle with all the charm and otherworldly grace one would expect from an elf. Tolkien's elves aren't a bunch of pointy eared midgets, they are tall, proud, delicate people with an intense inner power. Bloom embodies all of that and more. He's not just a pair of Spocklike ears.

Then there's Liv, whose much-advertised role boils down to only a few minutes. Yet in those few precious ticks of the clock, she stands bravely on the screen to command those moments, and steal your heart. She doesn't overshadow the film, she doesn't steal scenes, she just lights up her lines with the quiet energy of an ethereal being. Whiny fans fear not, Liv does Arwen justice.

Unlike other fantasy films, where the heroes spend most of their time running to and fro from various monsters in the bushes, Lord of the Rings delivers REAL moments of terror and dread. Not from some artificial rubber monster, but from a sense of REAL evil and danger and imminent destruction that permeates the scenes. The best part is, that not all of that comes from dark lords and big name baddies alone. Even the good guys can scare the shit out of you, as the evil One Ring works its power to twist and destroy everyone around it. Jackson crafts that heart wrenching tension so perfectly, that it's nearly impossible not to buy into it.

FOTR is not an absolutely perfect film. There are a couple of moments where things get a bit awkward, as Jackson struggles to come to grips with his need to watch the clock and indulge Tokien's exquisitely detailed fantasy. Only, those are so quickly forgotten as viewers become lost in a bevy of character interaction and luscious storytelling, that they almost make no difference at all.

Peter Jackson and his cast are the stuff of legends. How can I, how can any of us live until we see the next installment?

The Disc: dvd

Hey! You've seen the movie, what about the DVD?

In stores as of August 6th is the first DVD release for The Fellowship of the Ring. It is one of two scheduled for this year. Why two? This first release is a 2-disc set containing the theatrical version of the film. The second is a 4-disc affair, scheduled for release in November and containing ONLY a Special Edition version of the film with a full 30 minutes of additional footage (Note: the third release, scheduled for December is just a re-release of the 4-disc set in fancy packaging with a pair of LOTR book-ends included!)

This presents an interesting dilemma for Fellowship of the Ring fans. Which do I buy? If you buy the first, you'll miss out on the additional footage, if you buy the second you'll miss out on owning the ORIGINAL theatrical version of the film. For me, it means I'm biting the bullet and buying Fellowship twice.

Tuesday, I took the first step, headed to Target on my lunch break, and picked up my copy of The Lord of the Rings: Fellowship of the Ring on DVD in a 2-disc set. Though I didn't exactly have a DVD player handy at work, I couldn't resist instantly tearing off the sticky annoying packaging, common to all DVD's and popping the case open. I was surprised to discover that that New Line had the whit to put it together in a nicely done fashion. Inside was of course the obligatory DVD booklet, three folds and a few pictures, nothing to thrilling of course. But the packaging itself appears to be of uncommonly high quality. Nice thick plastic holding those 2 DVD's in, with the second DVD attached to a well made loose-leaf partition that flops back and forth in the center of the case. Unlike a lot of the DVD's in my limited collection, I won't have to worry about breaking the case the first time I take it out of the house.

It didn't take long for me to get home that night. It was Tuesday and I usually work late, but instead I slyly snuck out the door early, DVD clutched tightly in hand as I worked my way home through raging Dallas traffic. A stop for a burrito (an important component in any DVD viewing experience) and then I was home, punching on my stereo and popping in the "Special Features" disc first, to see just what New Line had in store.

The menus are well done and fairly creative... but not exactly flashy. Navigation is easy, and features are broken down into reasonable categories. A quick inspection reveals that most of the features contained on the disc are things I've already seen. The biggest being the Houghton-Mifflin LOTR special that was shown in-stores prior to Fellowship's release. At the time it was exciting and I spent a good deal of energy hunting down a location to see it. Now there’s not much point in watching it again, having already seen the film. The rest are an assortment of "making of" videos, most of which have already been aired on television, or on the official Lord of the Rings website shortly before Fellowship's release in 2001. I watched them all, learning about Viggo's surprising skill with the sword and chuckling as portly Peter Jackson attempts to run "hobbit like" through the forest to demonstrate to his actors how he wants it done. It is great too, to see Christopher Lee, so obviously IN LOVE with his character. Even fun to be had in watching luscious Liv Tyler talk about speaking Elvish.

But... none of this is anything new. Nothing. In fact there's not one new feature, special, or item on this entire "Special Features" DVD pertaining to Fellowship of the Ring. Granted, non-uber fans may have missed seeing some of this old stuff before, so it's great to have it on there. Still, if you're a LOTR nut, doubtless you've seen every bit of this material months ago, and will be left wishing for more.

Well, there is more. The big new feature, which to my mind is probably the biggest reason beyond the film itself to buy it, is a ten-minute "making of" teaser on the work currently underway on the next film installment "The Two Towers". Opening with an intro by Peter Jackson himself (speaking from inside his rather beat up looking car) it rehashes much of the footage from the four-minute teaser shown a few months back attached to Fellowship. However, it adds in a great deal more detail, as well as a host of well shot and interesting behind the scenes footages.

All told, the second disc contains a little over 2 hours of feature material. Except for the Two Towers info, none of it's new, but all of it worth watching again and again.

What really matters is the movie itself... and in the case of this release, it couldn't be better done. The transfer is spectacular and crisp, with several options for enhancing viewing. The sound is top notch, again, lots of options for people with big booming surround sound systems. For this set, the movie fits on one disc, so rumors of it spanning two should be shoved back to the release of the next DVD set.

Lord of the Rings: Fellowship of the Ring, the theatrical edition, is a must have version of the soon to be classic film. Uber-fans will want to make it a point to buy the 4-disc set in November as well, but don't let its impending release fool you into passing this one up. Granted, it's more than a little light on truly insightful features (how about some commentary PJ!) but what really matters is the movie itself.






Reviewed By: Joshua Tyler

Release Details
Length: 178 min
Rated: PG-13
Distributor: New Line Cinema
Release Date:  2001-12-19
Starring: Elijah Wood, Ian McKellen, Viggo Mortensen, Sean Astin, Liv Tyler, John Rhys-Davies, Billy Boyd, Dominic Monaghan, Orlando Bloom, Sean Bean
Directed by: Peter Jackson
Produced by: Peter Jackson
Written by: J.R.R. Tolkien (book), Peter Jackson, Frances Walsh, Phillipa Boyens
Visit the The Lord of the Rings: Fellowship of the Ring Official Website
comment
blog comments powered by Disqus
FROM THE WEB
NEW REVIEWS
TOP MOVIES
HOT TOPICS