New Apollo vs. Old Apollo
Well, New Apollo looks cool but come on... look at old Apollo's hair.
Edge: Old BSG
New Adama vs Old Adama
So who could be cooler than Edward James Almos? The guy spoke 8 words during the entire run of Miami Vice. He also played a teacher with very bad hair. Who could beat that? Lorne Greene, dude! He starred in Bonanza AND Alpo Dog Food Commercials! I dunno..too close to call
Edge: Even
New Starbuck vs Old Starbuck
New Starbuck is a pretty young thang with moxie. Dirk Benedict, the old Starbuck, was a pretty young thang with moxie. Tie breaker is who starred in A-Team? I pity the foo who don't pick Dirk!
Edge: Old BSG
New Cylon vs Old Cylon
Um... do you need me to spell it out. Hottie vs a walking toaster. I like bagels but not as much as hotties!
Edge: New BSG
New XO Tigh vs Old Colonel Tigh
A black man replaced by an old white guy? Where's Al Sharpton? But new tigh is an alcoholic and cranky. I LOVE CRANKY
Edge: New BSG
New Boomer vs Old Boomer
The BLACK MAN gets no breaks! What does the Sci Fi Channel have against the proud black man? Then again.. I only wanna spoon with one boomer...and she's HOT! Alas... Old Boomer was always cool and I'll show him loyalty. This MAN won't be keepin Boomer down!.
EDGE: Old BSG
New Baltar vs Old Baltar
Hmm... New Baltar looks like a metrosexual. Old Baltar's eyebrows scare me.
Edge: New BSG
New Muffit vs Old Muffit
There is no new Muffit as of yet. THANK GOD! Look at that thing. What did they make that out of? Slurpee tops, shag rugs, and pipe cleaners?
Edge: New BSG
New Boxey vs Old Boxey
Jebus, look at their hair!! It hasn't changed! Horrible. Please let him find the Battlestar Barber
Edge: Even
********************************
********************************
Tale of the tape: THE NEW BATTLESTAR GALACTICA WINS!