I admit that I have not heard very much Christian music in my time. The depth of my exposure dates back to last year, when I had a girlfriend who played for a Christian rock band. I heard a few of her band’s cover songs; suffice it to say, we don’t talk much anymore.
It’s just too boring for me. This subgenre’s power lies more within its lyrical content than in the players’ musicianship, and even that’s debatable. A lot of the lyrics just seem trite.
“So praise the God who saves/ Praise the God who bled/ Praise the God who was nailed to a tree/ And wore our sins upon His head.”
“I need to cry…. cry/ Cry to my Jesus… cry/ Cry to the heavens/ Cause without You in my life.”
Sure, they could have been in genuine grief at the time of writing these lyrics, but there’s something to be said about the line between sincerity and cheese. Like a romantic comedy, they could deal with very real and delicate issues, but the result is a cliché not worth sharing artistically. Ironically, that’s the main draw for Christian music--the content, not the musical talent.
That’s my biggest problem with Christian music--any dude can pick up a guitar, be a mediocre player, write trite lyrics and be praised for it. It’s just too easy.
If I may bring this debate full circle--this old girlfriend I had, she played me a song that she loved. I told my friend this the following day and asked him to guess the chorus’ lyrics.
“What, were they,” he asked, “‘I love you Jesus/ Jesus is my saviour’?”
“Close,” I replied. “It was ‘Jesus, Jesus, Jesus, Jesus …’ over and over again.”
“Go figure.”
No!
-- Lexi Feinberg
Christian music has become so much more than just “praise the Lord Almighty” and “Hail Mary” chanted over notes. Sure, it is rooted with the same holy undercurrents, but, like any art, you have to take it at face value and decide what it means to you. Millions of people rocked out to Lifehouse’s “Hanging By A Moment” long before they realized it was written about Jesus. And who cares that it was?
Well, they do, apparently. It’s become common for Christian rock bands (some talented, some not) to try and avoid being pigeonholed as religious, even if that’s indeed what they are. Maybe they’re worried that it’s not exactly a sexy marketing campaign or that the godless folks of the world will run screaming when they learn the news. Either way, they choose to let the music do the talking.
As a non-believer, I personally like what I’m hearing. I think that Christian music has gotten a second wind of late. Talented groups such as the aforementioned Lifehouse, Switchfoot and Copeland have blended into the rock scene with their catchy riffs and accessible lyrics. Mute Math is a talented band that can bring a place down with its loud, infectious rock (download the awesome song “Typical” for proof), and even created a savvy homemade instrument called the Atari. And while Evanescence fails to please my eardrums, there is no denying the success the group has enjoyed since its debut.
That’s not to say there isn’t a ton of bad Christian music out there--that is an undeniable fact. There’s bad music everywhere, period. But there is a lot more creativity, experimentation and mainstream appeal coming out of religious rock than ever before.
And I’m keeping the faith, so to speak, that there’s plenty more where that came from.
Comment on “Great Debate: Has Christian Music Grown Stale?”
Note: This website is not meant for use by minors. The views expressed in the comments section below are not our own. This section is intended for discussion of the topic in the post above. Disagreement is encouraged, however comments which attack, insult, or threaten the author in a personal manner won't be published. Similarly, comments that we deem to be poorly worded, or wildly off topic will also not be approved and may be mocked. For free, uncensored, unfettered, and possibly dangerous discussion visit our forum.
This article is about, oh, seven years late. I've been listening to Christian Music since around 1999, starting with Jars of Clay when their song "Flood" hit mainstream radio and a lot of people didn't know it was about God. I'm going to say this: Michael Fraiman: Listening to Christian music for not even a year will make it seem like you think it is. One thing that you won't understand by visiting a Best Buy for Christian music is the variety of music available. The simple fact is: if best buy REALLY carried a good Christian section, it would be at least an entire length of an aisle, and split into separate genres. The music you're talking about is either praise or power praise. Also known as Praise and Worship. Many bands have done those P&W albums lately, and many have songs like that. That's perfectly fine. However, if you think that's all there is, you need to head back to the store, and check out any of the following bands/artists: The Afters, Anberlin, Mae, Mainstay, Newsboys, Relient K, Group 1 Crew, Future of Forestry, The Tide, Mark Schultz, TobyMac, Skillet, The Listening. You'll find that christian music reaches far beyond what you're thinking it does. I'd give you a rundown of the style of each of the artists I've listed, but I think it's a pretty broad spectrum of musical stylings represented there. Heck, if you want a song on current events, Mark Schultz wrote a song called "Letters from War" that will touch your heart. He's an artist that anyone could get into, and would have made a great mother's day gift. Anyway, just thought I'd share a bit (I don't only listen to Christian music, but it is the area that most of my music collection falls).
I say so long as they omit Jesus from the lyrics, it's all good. Nothing agaist the J-dog, but it can be tedious to hear an album where every song is a direct letter to someone so specific. It's a similar case if a band chronically references somebody named Sarah in every song, although no disrespect to Thin Lizzy.
It's interesting to note that an opinion that is a so-called attack on God merits hardly a whimper, but that the previous so-called attack on the Beatles resulted in a ton of controversy. Guess the Beatles are bigger than Jesus...
I was listening to Christian music in the mid-1980s, most notably Undercover and Steve Taylor, both of whom issued some very thoughtful music (though Undercover's late 80s records show more thought and depth than their early work). And a good case can be made that Amy Grant's work breaks the mold, as does the songwriting of U2.
The best Christian music, however, can be found in the Psalms. I admire O-Joe Taylor's (Undercover) work, but he hasn't anything to equal Psalm 22 yet.
This site is operated by Cinema Blend LLC. For advertising inquiries, contact Gorilla Nation. CinemaBlend.com is a private, independently owned website which is intended only as entertainment. The views expressed on this website may or may not reflect those of its owner. Don't take us too seriously.
May 22, 2007 at 10:59
May 24, 2007 at 17:46
October 15, 2007 at 02:28
September 22, 2008 at 10:54