This Rotten Week: Predicting Sin City: A Dame to Kill For, If I Stay Reviews And More
Rotten Watch Prediction
See a little of what Iím talking about in the trailer for If I Stay,
Thereís probably a really great movie somewhere in this thing, I just kind of doubt this film pulls it off. The subject matter is super heavy - young and in love teenager (Chloe Grace Moretz) on her way to a bright cello career loses her whole family in a car accident. She is left in a coma and the movie plays out in her out of body experience. But it looks overly dramatic and squishy, most likely too reliant on extracting every little bit of emotion and gravity (with a cool soundtrack of course) on its way to making Moretz decide if she should live or die. Again, it seems like it could be interesting, but I donít see it being universally accepted as a quality film.
The story is based on the book of the same title by Gayle Forman. Director R.J. Cutler has made a name for himself in the industry with documentary-style work both on the big screen and in television shows. Heís put together a solid resume when the subjects are "real". I donít know if itís going to translate completely here in the adaptation. When you try too hard to be dramatic, it can fall flat. Iím struggling to see how it all comes together with Moretzís possibly overlong out of body experience and the source material. It wonít finish in the basement, but I donít predict critics will be kind.
Back to top