This Rotten Week: Predicting Sin City: A Dame to Kill For, If I Stay Reviews And More
Rotten Watch Prediction
1. Friday Night Lights (T.V. Show) - So good it counts as a movie
2. Remember the Titans - cheesy but eminently re-watchable
2A. Friday Night Lights (Movie) - Only seems worse because show was so good.
4. All the Right Moves - Doesnít exactly hold up, but whatever. Itís still good.
5. Varsity Blues - A lesser American classic.
These rankings are absolute and irrefutable. Will this newest high school football film crack the top five? I think we can come to a pretty quick conclusion by watching the trailer for When the Game Stands Tall below:
The answer is "No". If the trailer is to be believed, When the Game Stands Tall appears more an ABC Family movie than a film with any real stakes. Iím sure the filmmakers work to provide healthy doses of drama in and around the story of De La Salle High Schoolís epic winning streak through the Ď90s and early Ď00s. But this drama appears artificial and stale. Again, a trailer does not a movie make, but if itís supposed to tell the story of the filmís major beats then we are looking at a football flick that could become instantly forgettable.
Director Thomas Carter has some experience in the "undefeated high school sports team" realm, having previously made Coach Carter (65%). Itís not a bad film, but it could lay the groundwork for how we perceive his latest. Coach Carter was a safe, albeit fine, fine movie that stuck to the sports drama playbook with more than its share of "feel good" to it. When the Game Stands Tall feels like it will cram a lot in without ever really getting anywhere.
Because Iím the definitive voice on high school football movies, Iíll be forced to see it and properly rank itís slot in movie history. But the odds arenít great. Thereís too much drama, not enough at stake, and no Coach Taylor.
Back to top
GET US IN YOUR FEED