movie reviews, movie news, dvd, and movie discussion
Reviews Upcoming Podcast Forums Tech

Sicko Controversy Continues

By Josh Tyler: 2007-06-12 00:19:33
Sicko Controversy Continues Michael Moore is a genius, at least when it comes to getting rich. Here’s the Michael Moore guide to making a lot of money. Step 1: Make a completely contrived propaganda film full of trumped up melodrama and fear-mongering, reactionary voice-overs that tell people how to think. Call the movie a documentary. Step 2: Do something so irresponsible and stupid that it gets you in minor legal trouble and then blow it completely out of proportion so you can pretend everyone is persecuting you for making that movie and play the victim to get your name in the papers.

Michael Moore started the victim phase of his Sicko production a month or so ago when the US Treasury began investigating him for traveling to Cuba with a group of 9/11 rescue works to shoot some sort of staged, contrived segment for his healthcare deficiencies propaganda movie. Oh, Moore claims his intention was to open the movie quietly and without controversy, but come on people, you’re not that stupid. Now Moore is lashing out against the United States government, and really upping the victimization ante. He’s calling the investigation a “discriminatory attack” and accusing the United States government of harassment.

Basically, the whole thing is turning into a big public mess of name calling. In an effort to defend themselves against Moore’s accusation the government has released the letter they sent him and accused Michael Moore of trumping up a smear campaign against the Bush administration. If I were the Treasury Department, I wouldn’t worry so much about Bush. It’s not like his approval ratings can get any worse.

Here’s the thing: It basically sounds like Michael Moore is admitting he broke the law. The Hollywood Reporter seems to indicate he flat out says he went to Cuba for his documentary, and he did it without a permit. He applied for one, but didn’t wait for it to be issued and approved before he went traipsing with his cameras into the land of Castro. The cynic in me says he did that on purpose, just to generate publicity for the movie when the US government started investigating him, but I can’t prove that. I do know that I can’t just hop a plane jaunt off to Cuba, so why does Michael Moore think he should be allowed to? Carrying a camera with you isn’t a get out of jail free card.

As for whether or not he’s being persecuted, so far the only thing anyone has done to Michael Moore as far as I can tell, is to send him a letter saying his trip is being looked into. It’s not like the CIA has formed a ring around his house and is preparing to shoot tear gas in through the windows. Moore however justifies it this way, “subjects of the work of journalists are transported by (journalists) all the time. We were acting not just as journalists but as human beings (to help) rescue workers. ... Take off your journalistic hats for a moment -- does this upset anyone?” So basically what he’s saying is that he did something wrong but it doesn’t upset anyone so it’s ok… is that it? The mind boggles. I’m sure Paris Hilton used a similar argument to get the cops to let her out of prison. Boy was she wrong.

Michael Moore, you make me crazy. The bitch of him, to me anyway, is that I agree with a lot of his viewpoints. Sicko for instance is about what a mess the US Healthcare system is, and I’d really like to get behind someone getting up off their ass to say something about the work that needs to be done on our medical system. But Moore’s methods and behavior are so completely abhorrent that he utterly undermines his own viewpoint with his rabble-rousing, media-whoring, manipulative behavior. My fear here is that Sicko is going to be just another example of it, and in the process undermine anything legitimate other more respectable people have to say about on the subject.



Latest Headlines:

 

Comment on “Sicko Controversy Continues”

Note: This website is not meant for use by minors. The views expressed in the comments section below are not our own. This section is intended for discussion of the topic in the post above. Disagreement is encouraged, however comments which attack, insult, or threaten the author in a personal manner won't be published. Similarly, comments that we deem to be poorly worded, or wildly off topic will also not be approved and may be mocked. For free, uncensored, unfettered, and possibly dangerous discussion visit our forum.
  1. Mary Swanson Says:

    "My fear here is that Sicko is going to be just another example of it, and in the process undermine anything legitimate other more respectable people have to say about on the subject."

    So you agree with Moore's view on healthcare but think that the point he's making will be overlooked due to the fact that he is Michael Moore? I don't know, I think that if people see the movie, even if they're not a big fan of Michael Moore, they will at least try to learn more about the controversy and make a decision for themselves about it. I didn't know there was such a huge problem with our healthcare system until i saw some of the clips from Sicko, and I'm definitely going to go see the movie with an open mind. I say if Michael Moore makes us think, then he can keep making these movies.

  1. Aliza Zibkoff Says:

    I couldn't possibly agree with you more even if I had a nervous tick head-nod and all my fingers were thumbs (up)

    ANZ

  1. Josh T Says:

    Hi Mary,

    That's not exactly what I meant, though that may indeed play into it. I think a lot of people have already switched off to anything Moore does from now on.

    But more than that, I feel that the way Moore presents his material is disingenuous, and he often undermines his own point by using easy to see through propaganda tactics to make it. Even when he's right, he's wrong because he doesn't try to win people over with facts, but with misleading manipulation and half-truths.

  1. me Says:

    This is such an obvious publicity stunt. I'll give the guy credit. He's good at getting reactions. His whole career is based on that. I just wish he would make films that showed both sides of whatever issue he's exposing. He seems to care more about making people look stupid than anything.

  1. Gayle B. Says:

    I think you are absolutely right! Americans are switching off simply because most live in a state of denial. The average American has become so politically correct that they do not have enough intestinal fortitude to stand up for the truth, and they will use every defense mechanism to avoid facing the truth.

    I applaud Michael for his intestional fortitude to attempt uncover the corruption and self centeredness of our elected officials and their big business buddies and PACs.

    Although Cuba is a communist country, as Americans, we are free to go anywhere we like, so why is his going to Cuba even an issue? No one seemed to care when Jesse Jackson traveled to another country in which we were having political differences. Since when do Americans have to ask for permission to travel anywhere they choose?

    As for Michael Moore's not making friends, that is just an example of the point I made above about upper middle class Americans living in a state of oblivion. To Josh T. who wrote in, it isn't about making friends; it's about giving people like you a wake up call! I would be willing to guess that you haven't been in a situation where you needed expert health care from a doctor of your choice that you trusted.

    Before we bash someone for trying to give us a wake up call, maybe we should open our minds, our ears, and look outside our comfort zones and then make an educated decision about America's health care system.

Leave a Reply




Back to Sicko Controversy Continues

MAIN SITE NAVIGATION
HOME l ABOUT US l l SEARCH l MOVIE NEWS l MOVIE REVIEWS l MOVIE PREVIEWS l DVD REVIEWS l DVD NEWS l SOUNDTRACKS l FEATURES DATABASE l TELEVISION l MUSIC l GAMES l CELEBRITY l TECHNOLOGY l RSS 2.0 FEEDS l MESSAGE BOARDS l LIVE CHAT l SYNDICATE US l LINKS | CB STORE | MUNCH MONSTER


This site is operated by Cinema Blend LLC. For advertising inquiries, contact Gorilla Nation. CinemaBlend.com is a private, independently owned website which is intended only as entertainment. The views expressed on this website may or may not reflect those of its owner. Don't take us too seriously.

Made in Webta Labs
SITE SEARCH
SITE FEEDS


 
HOT TOPICS
batman 3 news
the hobbit news
iron man 2 news
pirates of the caribbean news star trek news
transformers news
MORE FROM CB