This Rotten Week: Predicting Last Airbender And Twilight: Eclipse Reviews

By Doug Norrie 2010-06-27 12:55:40discussion comments
fb share tweet share
This Rotten Week: Predicting Last Airbender And Twilight: Eclipse Reviews image
Armond White strikes again. Usually I recap the previous week at the end, but I wanted to just mention something about this guy. Last week, I predicted Grown Ups would be a pile of monkey dung. It failed to live up to even basement level expectations (Predicted 19%, Actual 10%). Only ten percent of critics thought this movie was worth shelling out ten bucks to see at the theater. White, the same guy who panned Toy Story 3, thinks this Adam Sandler, fart joking, cash grab, was a quality flick. I guess my question is: when can someone lose their critic credentials? Do such things exist? Can someone get on this? I want this guy out. (Although I guess he did help my prediction be a little more accurate, so maybe I should thank him.)

Anyway, this week teeny-boppers everywhere will begin to lose their minds over another installment of Robert Pattinson’s Deep, Brooding Looks and kids will have a new reason to suck money out of their parents’ wallets in an effort to see Aang and friends defeat the Fire Lord. Let’s take a look at what This Rotten Week has to offer.

The Twilight Saga: Eclipse

I don’t have a history with the Twilight franchise never having picked up one of the books (although, I did read one Stephanie Meyer book, The Host and thought it was horrible) and having seen only the beginning of the first movie (turned it off after a half hour). So, label me non-plussed about seeing this next installment of the dark, teen angst-filled, vampire drama that sends girls jumping off cliffs for the chance to see Robert Pattinson scowl, Taylor Lautner look confused, and Kristen Stewart choose between them.

Judging from the trailer, here is what happens in Eclipse: Kristen Stewart talks to Pattinson. Then they walk together. Then they lie down and talk some more. Then she talks to Lautner. Then she talks to Pattinson again. Then it’s back to Lautner. Then Lautner and Pattinson talk with each other. Then a red haired girl jumps over a lake. Then everyone talks a little bit more. Then Lautner takes his shirt off. Roll credits.

I know some Twilight fans (or all 10 billion of you) will probably take umbrage with my dismissal of this entire series of movies, but hey I gave them a chance (even if it wasn't much of one). They stink. The big question here is whether Eclipse can, ahem, eclipse New Moon’s (27%). When the bar is already set so low, it’s tough to know where to go. Director David Slade (30 Days of Night) replaces Chris Weitz (The Golden Compass) so that’s effectively a push. It's rare that new installments in a lackluster franchise light world on fire compared to their predecessors since they’re all working with the same material (and actors). The Rotten Watch for The Twilight Saga: Eclipse is 23%.

The Twilight Saga: Eclipse reviews


The Last Airbender

M. Night Shymalan’s run as a director has been the tale of two careers. Between 1999 and 2002 he whipped out Sixth Sense, Unbreakable and Signs to the tune of an average 76% Tomatoemeter score. He then follows those hits up with The Village, Lady in the Water and The Happening with an average of 28%. That's quite a drop off for a director who less than a decade ago seemed like a total “can’t miss”. So where does that leave The Last Airbender? It’s tough to say, since Shyamalan has basically ditched his standard, “Just wait, the big twist is coming,” features to direct a live action adaptation of a popular animated series. Oh M. Knight, we hardly knew ye.

It’s awfully tempting to predict The Last Airbender as a critical bust since this is M. Knight’s first real foray into a big budget action movie and the trailer looks pretty cheesy. But there is reason for a little optimism. Nickelodeon Movies (teaming with Paramount) have a decent adaptation track record with The Spiderwick Chronicles (79%), Charlotte’s Web (78%) and Lemony Snicket’s A Series of Unfortunate Events (71%). But then I see Hotel for Dogs and Imagine That and think, yeah it’s not all great.

I want M. Night to make a comeback. The guy was just too good early in his career. But it just doesn’t seem like The Last Airbender is the movie that reignites the critical flame for him. Will it make a ton at the box office? Probably, it’s a kid’s movie after all and the little ones are nothing if not movie money sinks. But from a critical perspective, The Last Airbender will be more of the same for Mr. Shyamalan. The Rotten Watch for The Last Airbender is 43%.

The Last Airbender reviews



Poll

Which Rotten movie will have the highest final Tomatometer score?

  Results


Recapping last week: I already waxed non-poetic on Grown Ups and Katey Rich thought it was a steaming piece of crap too. Meanwhile Tommy Cruise just barely kept another movie on the positive side with Knight and Day (Predicted 66%, Actual 53%) splitting critics down the middle (and pretty much tanking at the box office). All in all, another good week for the Rotten Watch.

Next week, Steve Carrell goes despicably into the animated world and Robert Rodriguez brings the predator back into our lives. It’s going to be a Rotten Week!
discussion
Subscribe To Topics You're Interested In
Comments
blog comments powered by Disqus
Back to top
RELATED
FROM THE WEB
NEW REVIEWS
FEATURES
TOP MOVIES
HOT TOPICS
TRAILERS