It’s been two years since we first heard of the plan to bring the Broadway musical Wicked to the big screen, but is producer Marc Platt finally taking steps toward making it a reality? According to Deadline, that’s exactly what’s happening. Apparently Platt, book writer Winnie Holzman and songwriter Stephen Schwartz are on the hunt for a director and JJ Abrams, James Mangold, Ryan Murphy and Rob Marshall are all in the running.

Let’s leave the potential directors aside for a moment. What took so long? With the musical itself having broken a number of Broadway box office records and moviegoers clamoring for more stage to film adaptations like Hairspray and Mamma Mia! , in some cases regardless of quality, Wicked The Movie is practically a guaranteed hit. That being said, it would also be quite the travesty to ruin such a fantastic piece of material and this is where the director issue comes into play.

The stage production has a handful of dark moments, yet, like most musicals, it’s lighthearted, but not campy like Mamma Mia!. JJ Abrams just seems all wrong for the job. Should Wicked actually come to fruition, it should be a family piece and there isn’t much on Abrams’ resume that appeals to all four quadrants. James Mangold, on the other hand, could be a good option. He’s got a nice mixture of material under his belt, from dark and disturbing pieces like Girl, Interrupted and Identity to Kate & Leopold, a romantic comedy. He’s even got some musical experience having directed Walk the Line.

It’s quite obvious why Ryan Murphy is being tossed in the mix – Glee. The guy produced and wrote all 22 episodes, served as executive music producer for 21 of them and directed five. I happen to love the show, but that doesn’t mean I’m behind him making the switch from TV musicals to big screen ones. In fact, his experience with Glee could actually work against him, potentially influencing his stylistic decisions for a feature project. Nobody will be happy with a Wicked movie that looks as though it could have just been a theme night for Glee. Lastly we’ve got Rob Marshall and my argument for him comes down to this: it’ll be quite a while before I can forgive him for Nine.

At this point, I’m pulling for Mangold, but Universal could really do better. Why not just stick with a good thing and go with the show’s director Joe Mantello? He’s barely got any filmmaking experience, having directed only some 1997 film called Love! Valour! Compassion! , but perhaps a director that hasn’t been tainted by the big budget Hollywood machine will be exactly what the project needs to preserve the show’s assets.

Blended From Around The Web

Related

Hot Topics

New Reviews

Top Movies

Features

Gateway Media ©copyright 2016