Writer Jokes Jay-Z Should Rename Nets The N-----s, Funny Or Fireable Offense?
Longtime New York Post writer Phil Mushnick is no stranger to controversy. Heís been feuding with radio host Mike Francesa and WWE head Vince McMahon for what feels like decades. As such, itís not a big surprise one of his columns has drawn angry calls for his firing, but for once, his critics might actually have a point.
Hereís what Mushnick wrote today about Jay-Zís influence over the Brooklyn NetsÖ
As long as the Nets are allowing Jay-Z to call their marketing shots ó what a shock that he chose black and white as the new team colors to stress, as the Nets explained, their new ďurbanĒ home ó why not have him apply the full Jay-Z treatment?
As someone who writes about pop culture for a living, Iím well aware jokes or intended social commentaries are sometimes misinterpreted by readers. I think itís pretty obvious from the above words Mushnick was trying to use Jay-Zís own lyrics to say something larger about his viewpoint. Unfortunately, even taking that into account, the comments still drip of old white guy pretention, bad taste and perhaps even racism. Not every ďthoughtful commentĒ is free of bias, and not every personal opinion needs to be uttered, not even if the speaker is paid for his opinions.
As of press time, itís unclear whether Mushnick will lose his job over this mess. Those who think his termination would be rash have argued Free Speech allows him the freedom to say whatever he wants. That might be true, but a newspaper also has the right to fire someone for giving the opinions Free Speech allows in a less than diplomatic way.
I donít see how this is funny at all, but maybe Iím just missing the boat. Maybe his words were actually witty social commentary. What do you think? Should he lose his job over this?
Should This Cost The Writer His Job?
For more questions of the day, head here.