Winter Passing - Review

Discuss this movie on our message board!

Length: 99 min

Rated: R

Distributor: The Yari Film Group

Release Date: 2006-02-17

Starring: Ed Harris, Will Ferrell, Zooey Deschanel, Amelia Warner

Directed by Adam Rapp

Produced by P. Jennifer Dana, David Koplan

Written by Adam Rapp

Visit the movie's Official Site!

Reviewed by Edward Darell : 2006-02-21 15:22:07

Legendary producer Sam Goldwyn supposedly said, in reference to movies with a message, "If you want to send a message, call Western Union". The writer-director of Winter Passing, playwright Adam Rapp, might well have heeded that warning. Take the film's poster: "Sometimes you go looking for what you want and find what you need." Next, check out the trailer: "Sometimes the hardest journey you can take is the one that takes you"... "Sometimes the people you need the most are the ones you know the least." Get the message?"

Winter Passing is Rapp's first film. Set in New York and the rural Midwest, it's the story of Reese Holden (Zooey Deschanel), a young aspiring actress living in a messy apartment with a sick kitten. She auditions, she acts, she snorts coke and has sex with one guy in a toilet, tells another to get lost the morning after. She mopes. A lot. Poor Reese. Oh, and she has a habit of slamming her fingers in desk drawers, presumably to blunt her psychic pain with a dose of the real thing. Something must really be wrong. "What are you so mad at?" asks one of her male friends, a fellow actor so frustrated with life in New York that he's ready to move to Colorado to be around real people and cows. And away, presumably, from the likes of Reese. Reese mopes some more. Plays the piano. Drowns her cat.

Reese's father, Don Holden (Ed Harris), is a National Book Award-winning writer who hasn't published a thing in years. Reese's mother, also a writer, is dead, and Reese didn't attend the funeral.

Following a performance, a book editor (Amy Madigan) accosts Reese at the stage door and offers her a large sum of money for a pack of letters exchanged between her parents long ago. She wants to publish them. Reese is noncommittal, and with the moral purity of the truly angry and depressed turns down air fare home and elects to take the bus.

Arriving at the family home, Reese is greeted at the door by Corbit (Will Ferrell), and is asked for I.D. Weirdo alert! Corbit is some kind of lost soul who showed up on Don Holden's couch one night and never left. A puppy dog kinda guy who's a few Kibbles short of a bag. Don himself lives in the garage, amidst piles of books, and clacks spasmodically at an ancient Underwood when he isn't having the DT's. Don is obviously, in addition to being a National Drinking Award-winning drunk, A Man in Pain.

Rounding out the household is Shelly (Amelia Warner), a former student of Don's who may or may not be sleeping with him. Familiar message: award-winning, drunken, self-pitying, blocked writers can still get laid. Or maybe not. Predictably, Shelly and Reese have at it. Ferrell's rendering of Corbit, who, it turns out, used to be in a rock band but couldn't play and sing at the same time, seems influenced by the actor's turn as an ersatz Woody Allen in Melinda and Melinda, prone to goofy, self-conscious, unfunny asides. Ferrell acts like he's not only wandered into Don Holden's life, he's also wandered onto the set of the film from the land of Odd. He's dazed, confused, paranoid, wears eyeliner, and most alarming, a Foreigner t-shirt. Corbit and Don play golf every day in an empty bedroom, wearing old football helmets and half the contents of the kitchen as armor. Meanwhile, the bedroom furniture sits in the back yard. Message: this is one fucked-up menage.

Family secrets are unearthed and buried again, wrongs are set right, but to little avail. Its array of positive messages and billing as a "dramedy" notwithstanding, Winter Passing is basically a bummer. The writing is superficially clever and stagey, the characters and situations forced and lacking credibility. The assumption seems to have been made that angst in and of itself is interesting. The lack of back story to the characters makes their actions inexplicable, and the gaps in the narrative are too wide to fill in. Ferrell, surely, was given a lot of leeway to ad-lib, as it's hard to believe anyone would have written a lot of what comes out of his mouth. Things are set right, at the end, by facile, familiar old road-trippy solutions.

Deschanel commits the least sins of all the actors, given what she has to work with. Her anger and bitterness are convincing enough, but they seem to exist in a vacuum. Harris does little but play the self-pitying drunk. Amelia Warner's character is boring, just another star-struck writer-groupie, and, lest I forget, like Reese's kitten she's sick too, only Reese doesn't drown her.

The twists of the plot are predictable, and the film has a paint-by-numbers quality. The sound track is suitably mopey and emo-heavy. Adam Rapp has filmed what is at best a first-draft screenplay. The film doesn't work. That is my message to you. Over and out.

Latest Movie Reviews:

Star Wars: The Clone Wars

Henry Poole Is Here

Fly Me to the Moon 3D

Thumbnails Gallery for Winter Passing

Social Bookmark This Article

Blinklist

Del.icio.us

Digg

Furl

Slashdot

Facebook

StumbleUpon

Yahoo!

Propeller

Comment on “Winter Passing”

Note: This website is not intended for use by minors. The views expressed in this comments section are not necessarily our own. Comments that we deem to be poorly worded, off topic, or threatening will not be published. For free, uncensored discussion visit our forum.

jeremy butler Says:
July 23rd, 2006 at 22:09
i live in michigan in the u.p and am pissed off about how they represented us up here we are not drunks and we certainly arent miserable we are away from all the city problems and most of us couldnt be happier =)

kenny boy Says:
July 31st, 2006 at 22:32
Absolutly right about that. I grew up in the west end town of White pine and loved it and also lived in curtis. I loved and valued everything about it. Cheers to you for the comment.

Holly Says:
August 30th, 2006 at 19:19
I too am originally from the UP (Escanaba). Although I loved growing up there, I do have to admit that many small towns (not just in the UP) have a culture that promotes alcoholism. Of course not everyone drinks excessively, many people (most) live healthy lives, but I definately didn't think it was misrepresented.

However, my question is, could you figure out exactly where it is supposed to be? I was thinking somewhere b/w Newberry and Sault Ste. Marie. They mention Whitefish Point and he taught at a University.... Any ideas? Did they say where and I just missed it? At open-mic night Will Farrel's character only refered to it as the UP.

Johnna Calverase Says:
April 22nd, 2007 at 17:37
Well, I had to stop watching this self indulgent pice of crap when it came to drowing the kitten.

There are lots of other ways to express this girls perpetual bummer and self loathing state beside showing the drowing of a kitten. This sends a message that is ok to portray animal abuse to tell a story, and a really crappy story at that. You lost me at Kitten Abuse.

There are many things that go on in this world that we dont need to have played in pictures to get a point across....and this is one of them. Do we really need to see her drown a kitten to get this lousy films point across.

Remind me to purposely never watch this loser-writer-directors films anymore.

Deanna Says:
March 3rd, 2008 at 01:19
Somehow I managed to pick this movie in from my cabel company On Demand line-up. Before I knew what was happening, I was watching a kitten being drowned..before I even could find my remote to turn the thing off. How this movie could have found me tonite....I am the Director of a cat rescue for god's sake?! I can only say one thing, animal abuse, even if in the mind of the author of this story, is directly correlated to people abuse. I feel sorry for the people who are in the lives of this author. The fact that that an entire movie production effort went on supporting including this component of the story is unbelievable. It is irresponsible. And the scene is still haunting me.

Back to Winter Passing

Winter Passing - Review

Social Bookmark This Article

Comment on “Winter Passing”

Leave a Reply