movie reviews, movie news, dvd, and movie discussion
Upcoming Forums Video

American Idol: America Sends Sanjaya Home

By Kelly West: 2007-04-18 21:58:27
American Idol: America Sends Sanjaya Home It was country music week on ‘American Idol’ and Martina McBride was on hand to give the final seven contestants some advice and support. If I were a betting woman, based on last night’s performance, added to her previous performances, I’d put money down on Jordin Sparks to win this thing with Melinda Doolittle as a very close second. As for everyone else, it was a weak week for the remaining idol-hopefuls. While six contestants will have at least one more week to prove themselves worthy, it was the end of the road for Sanjaya Malakar.

Malakar has had some support from a variety of sources ranging from genuine fans to the vote-for-the-worst people. Though his talent didn’t match most of the other singers in this season’s top twelve, I give him credit for holding his head high and having a good sense of humor towards the whole situation. He’s young and there’s still time for him to develop his vocal abilities and make something of himself as a musician someday.

LaKisha squeaked by this week by the skin of her teeth. In the last few rounds she’s failed to find a song that really compliments that big voice of hers. Blake slipped down into the bottom three this week proving that one imperfect performance is all it takes to lose the attention of the voters.

Who Should Have Gone Home Tonight?

  Results

Last night, Sanjaya Malakar gave the judges and Ryan “Something To Talk About” after a seriously sub-par performance of the Bonnie Raitt hit. Ryan, who seemed on edge last night, was far less jest-y than he normally is when exchanging words with Simon. The judges raved about Phil Stacey’s performance and had positive things to say about Chris Richardson and Blake Lewis as well but to be honest; I didn’t think any of them were all that great.

Jordin was on fire last night and Melinda wins the prize for finding the perfect song to compliment her voice. Both girls have proven themselves more than worthy of this competition. That said, how on earth did Blake end up in the bottom three? Sure last night wasn’t his best performance but it was a lot better than Chris Richardson’s.

In tonight’s results show, the final contestants got together to perform the usual group number. Normally I don’t really care much for this performance but tonight was a definite exception. They performed “I’m Alright” and amazingly enough, everyone sounded great! Each solo performance was on key and when they sang the chorus together, the harmony was perfect with no one singer dominating the song. My compliments to whoever arranged this number and of course, to the idols for performing it so well.

Here are my thoughts on the remaining contestants:


American IdolMelinda Doolittle
Brentwood, TN
The top three should be a lock for her at this point in the competition. She sang a country song and was rightfully compared to the great Tina Turner. Melinda has proven time and again that no matter what the genre, she can adapt. She’s a pop-star in the making.


American IdolLaKisha Jones
Fort Meade, MD
Unfortunately, LaKisha hasn’t had as easy a time at adapting to different genres as Melinda. I agreed with the judges in their criticisms of last night’s performance. She over-sang the song and it felt almost like she lost control of her voice at times. She’s got so much voice but she needs to have better control of it if she wants to avoid the bottom three next week.

American IdolBlake Lewis
Bothell, WA
I really didn’t care much for Blake’s performance last night. It wasn’t bad and he’s still definitely one of my favorites but he can definitely do better. Hopefully next week he’ll bring it back with a solid performance. Maybe something up-beat with a little beat-boxing since we haven’t heard much of that in the last few weeks.


American IdolChris Richardson
Chesapeake, VA
Chris is another one who is starting to stand out as a just-ok singer at this point. I found last night’s performance to be one of his worst yet. He seemed to have a hard time really connecting with the song he was singing. He’s a good-looking guy but I don’t think he has the talent or the charisma to really be amazing. Plus his shout out to Virginia Tech felt ill timed and inappropriate considering he did it right as Ryan was announcing his voting number. While his intentions were probably innocent, it just seemed like bad form to me.


American IdolJordin Sparks
Glendale, AZ
This girl gets better and better each week. It was an ambitious choice to go with McBride’s “Broken Wing” but she nailed it and might’ve even found the perfect B-side song for her first single. Great job, Jordin!


American IdolPhil Stacey
Jacksonville, FL
Phil’s performance this week was definitely an improvement from his previous performances but I wasn’t totally sold. He really needs to find that one amazing song to show the viewers/voters that he’s got what it takes to rival the better singers in this competition.


Did you think America made the right choice in allowing Sanjaya to go this week? Who would you have sent packing? Who do you think is most likely to win this year?



Latest Headlines:

 

Comment on “American Idol: America Sends Sanjaya Home”

Note: This website is not meant for use by minors. The views expressed in the comments section below are not our own. This section is intended for discussion of the topic in the post above. Disagreement is encouraged, however comments which attack, insult, or threaten the author in a personal manner won't be published. Similarly, comments that we deem to be poorly worded, or wildly off topic will also not be approved and may be mocked. For free, uncensored, unfettered, and possibly dangerous discussion visit our forum.

Subscribe to topic comments

  • My goal is to reach fans of Melinda Doolittle who want to support her with her career she will released her first album in fall and work on Holiday CD come join us www.mdstreetteam.com Keep yu upate about her.
  • Please remove the following posting. It was done by someone other than me. Thank you. Shon Tilby

    Shon Tilby Says:

    April 18th, 2007 at 22:40
    I am not a fan of country music, but I think that Sanjaya was cheated tonight. This gifted young singer MOVES ME! The way he lets his eyes move with the camera..it makes me have the feeling that he is looking at me, and just me. I don't want to get weird, I am a married man. But if I was a single girl, I would be voting for Sanjaya. Thank you. Shon Tilby

  • Country music was just not for you Sanjaya. I was devastated to see you go.And I think you handled all the biased and mean critiscism very very well. AI is now nothing without you. When your eyes look into the camera and you smile, you just take everyone's breath away. Keep your spirits up, you will have a great future! =)

  • I will miss Sanjaya terribly. He brought so much of excitement n interest 2 the show. I wd wait for AI just to see what he will do next. Simon Cowell is a nasty, racist bully who shd be ashamed on picking on a 17 yr old kid.

    As for the other contestants, they are so boring that I can't tell one from another except maybe Lakisha coz she's so obese LOL

    Here's wishing Sanjaya all the best in his career. We love u!
  • it's about effing time for sanjaya to go HOME!!! THANK YOU AMERICA FOR VOTING!!! WE HOPE JORDIN WINS _ GLAD YOU GOT A NEW HEARING AIDE BATTERY!!!
  • I'm disappointed. Simon was brutal to Sanjaya. I think he's a sweet fellow that is only trying to make it in the industry. I don't think he deserves to be verbally beaten by the likes of Simon, especially considering how poorly everyone else performed. I think Simon would have gone to the ends of the earth to ensure Sanjaya's exit.
  • Sanjaya-You have the "IT" Factor and you make me happy when you sing. Amercan Idol

    is not the place for you.

    You will make it and you've had a tremendous effect on people already.

    Did you know that the masses thought Bob Dillon was a bore when he was young?

    Continue to sing so I can hear you.

  • Good-bye-ya... Sanjaya... I always wished his sister made the cut... but he showed spunk and can now go out on his own like William Hung wirh "She bang-she bang..." or some other awful ditty.
  • American idol will never be the same without Sanjaya
  • THE WORLD DEFINITELY DOESN'T NEED A MALE VERSION OF BRITNEY SPEARS AND BY THE WAY MUSIC SHOULDN'T ONLY B ABOUT LOOKS IT SHOULD BE ABOUT WHAT IT ENTITLES "MUSIC" I'M GLAD SANJAYA IS GON CONTESTANTS LIKE BRANDON WERE KICKED OFF AND HE STILL SURVIVED ON THE SHOW. SOM CONTESTANTS WERE KICKED OFF FROM ONE BAD NIGHT HE HAD BAAAAD NIGHTS AND HE STILL SURVIVED. I AGREE WITH SIMON HE'S WAS HORRIBLE. BUT HERE'S IS SOM GOOD ADVICE HE HAS NICE HAIR AND HE SHOULD STICK WITH BLUES. EVERYTHING HE SANG EXCEPT THE LATIN SONG WAS BAD OTHER THAN THAT I HAVE A CAT WITH MORE TALENT.
  • HALLELUJAH! SANJAYA IS FINALLY GONE!
  • I'm so glad there is finally an end to Sanjaya! I couldn't take much more. Apparently the ones that voted for him were tone-deaf too. Now we can enjoy the ones that deserve to go on to the end.
  • He was only in the show that long to fill the quota and should have left a long long time ago.
  • I was a fan of American Idol till today...Sanjaya was far most the best performer, American Idol shouldn't just be just about music, If you want music there are so many people singing out here in America. American Idol should be about over all performance and Sanjaya definitely added some "spice" to this show. I'm sure I'll be missing him, I'm sure he'll make it bigger some other place than American Idol...At least no one is going to forget him...He's for sure an "Idol" He's only 17 and he made it this far...I can't wait for him to explode in future.
  • HALLELUJAH!! SANJAYA IS FINALLY GONE!
  • Its about time sanjaya is gone....... i love american idol but i couldn't stand it with sanjaya on there now i can watch it again yeahhhhh
  • While true that Sanjaya was not the nest vocalist....many could say that he has been one of the the best performers on The American Idol not only this year but including many others. Should he have been sent home this week? No.... Phil & LaKisha should have gone first since they are well overdone.... and ohhh soooo boring!!So, Sanjaya should have made it to the final four- Simon's comments notwithstanding ....The show will definately have fewer viewers next week with fewer voters.....Smile, Sanjaya, you deserve all the praise and happiness you have showered on us viewers who looked forward to your different hairdos, different clothes and different vocals each week....We look forward to seeing you soon on the tour,,,and in appearing on television shows and on your most assuredly successful cd's...Thanks for bringing us such happiness and something to smile about and talk about each week.... You are already missed.....Sherita :>)
  • I love music, and I LOVE Sanjaya! He moves me. His rythmic vocals and glistening eyes are magic. I can see why the girls love him. Let's face it, it's time for a breakthrough artist to win American Idol. Thank you. Nick Triesch
  • Sanjaya is better off to get out the freak show..these people can push sanjaya to become one more depressed person..God saved the poor kid...from you all suckers..
  • I am not a fan of country music, but I think that Sanjaya was cheated tonight. This gifted young singer MOVES ME! The way he lets his eyes move with the camera..it makes me have the feeling that he is looking at me, and just me. I don't want to get weird, I am a married man. But if I was a single girl, I would be voting for Sanjaya. Thank you. Shon Tilby
  • I thought that Sanjaya added some excitement to the program. I couldn't wait to see what his hair was like each week. The kid COULD sing, just didn't choose the best songs to match his voice. Besame Mucho was by far his best performance.
    As much as he made the show more interesting, it was his time to go. Poor kid getting booed in a baseball stadium. He didn't deserve that.
    It's such a shame he is gone, but I'm sure this is only the beginning for this young lad's career. ;)
  • All I have to say is that Melinda WILL win the competition and Blake WILL get second in the competitition and Jordin WILL be a close third. I also think that Phil, Lakisha, and Chris will be the next three to go. go figure eh?

    Results: Chris 6th, Phil 5th, Lakisha 4th, Jordin 3rd, Blake 2nd, and Melinda WILL win lol

Subscribe to topic comments

Leave a Reply

Please login or sign up to post reply




Back to American Idol: America Sends Sanjaya Home

MAIN SITE NAVIGATION
HOME l ABOUT US l l SEARCH l MOVIE NEWS l MOVIE REVIEWS l MOVIE PREVIEWS l DVD REVIEWS l DVD NEWS l SOUNDTRACKS l FEATURES DATABASE l TELEVISION l MUSIC l GAMES l CELEBRITY l TECHNOLOGY l RSS 2.0 FEEDS l MESSAGE BOARDS l LIVE CHAT l SYNDICATE US l LINKS | CB STORE | MUNCH MONSTER | GFR


This site is operated by Cinema Blend LLC. For advertising inquiries, contact Gorilla Nation. CinemaBlend.com is a private, independently owned website which is intended only as entertainment. The views expressed on this website may or may not reflect those of its owner. Don't take us too seriously.

Made in Webta Labs
SIGN IN


 
SITE FEEDS


 

MORE FROM CB