Grey's Anatomy Fans Express Their Disapproval (Updated!)

By Kelly West: 2007-06-07 20:38:47

While fans of ‘Jericho’ and ‘Veronica Mars’ are demanding more episodes of their favorite series from the shows’ respective networks, ‘Grey’s Anatomy’ fans are demanding better episodes and storylines from the writers of the show. While season 2 of the hit ABC series served to draw in millions of devoted fans, season 3 seems to have let many of those fans down. Ferry crashes, visits to the afterlife, infidelity, parents dying and so much more filled the season that appears to be getting more and more like a soap opera than a drama series.

Granted, when it comes to shows like ‘Grey’s,’ there is a fine line between soap opera and primetime drama series but the writers did prove in the first and second season that the show could find a good balance of drama and quality storytelling. This season it feels as though the writers have been dragging our favorite characters through so many different sub-plots and storylines that the heart of the series has gotten lost. Many of the fans (myself included) are beginning to lose faith in the writers’ abilities to deliver the same quality episodes that aired in season 2.

Once upon a time, when a show started sinking, fans had two options: jump ship or cringe as they watched the band play on as the ship went down. We’re in the age of the internet though and TV fans are eager to rise up in full force and make themselves heard when they’re unhappy.

We received an email, forwarded to us from a fan of ‘Grey’s Anatomy’, which basically unloads what many fans of the series are feeling about the third season of ‘Grey’s’. I had not intended to post the letter in its entirety here because its very long but when trying to find excerpts from it, I found that there was nothing I felt could be left out. I’d credit the person who wrote it but I don’t have their name. I invite them to email me if they would like me to include their name in the article. (See update below)

The writer is inviting fans of the show who agree that the series has gone downhill to go to www.greyswriters.com and post a comment expressing their thoughts on this season as well as their hopes that they will bring the series back to greatness when it returns in the fall.

“To Whom It May Concern:

This is an open letter requesting assistance, an SOS if you will, to SAVE OUR SHOW - Grey's Anatomy. We have lost faith in the producers and writers of what once was a wildly entertaining program. Through what we can only interpret as their arrogance and ignorance, the writers and producers have lost sight of the essential ingredients that made up a creative, high class, well acted, extraordinary primetime television program.

Grey's Anatomy, as we have known and loved it, is dying. A major fan revolt is taking place. We are deeply concerned that the producers and writers may not heed this warning before it is too late. There is a real risk that Season four will see a dramatic loss of Grey's Anatomy's viewing audience.

For the most part, fans are not upset because they do not like the story line. Rather we are concerned that Grey's Anatomy has lost its heart and soul. It no longer reflects the quirky, inventive, refreshing brilliance of the first two seasons, but rather has become as dark and twisty as one of its major characters.

We have lost faith in the writers. In blogs and podcasts, they have asked fans to hang in there and make the leap to season four. They have made promises regarding story lines that have not been delivered, and because they have done this so often, now fans have lost faith that they can or will deliver on any new declarations.

The loss of faith in the writers also extends to the inconsistency and incongruous nature of many of the major characters. Over time we have gotten to know the characters well, but many are no longer recognizable. Having characters behave one way in one episode and then a completely different way in the next is not only frustrating, but also points to lazy writing. Viewers lose both loyalty to the character and respect for the writers. Fans will only tolerate such poor characterization for a short time before they simply turn off the program. Even loyal fans will not stay tuned when they see the characters they know and love turned into schizophrenic marionettes.

As loyal viewers, we also are concerned that rather than challenging us to think about social issues, the program is degrading the importance of many of the desired norms in our society. Marriage, fidelity and pregnancy are trivialized. Such a depiction of the institution of marriage and the responsibility of pregnancy does not reflect normal society or reality. Of further concern, Shonda Rhimes' comment in her most recent podcast that women "cannot have it all" is patronizing to ALL women and the antithesis of the current state of society.

Perhaps our greatest concern is the latest ABC Grey's Anatomy writer's blog, in which Ms. Rhimes states that she has burned the show and the story lines to the ground in order to start again from scratch. Ms. Rhimes is taking the easy way out. Either she is spread too thin or is no longer capable of writing the minute detail required for the continued growth that should be expected in all the core characters, specifically Meredith or Derek. Increasingly she has come to rely on the blogs and podcasts to explain what is happening between the characters because what we see on the screen often leaves viewers baffled. A cynic might even believe that she waits to see the reaction of the audience, then uses the blog and podcast to offer explanations designed to placate fans, as well as empty platitudes and promises asking us to trust her to make it right. Because she fails to deliver, fans are quickly losing faith in her and the show. We will not watch next season if she persists in this direction. In addition, our disappointment in this season is so great that we will not buy the season three DVD. The season can only be described as pathetic with momentary glimpses of the old show that we love.

We also believe that Ms. Rhimes' decision to burn the show to the ground may mean she has "backed herself in to a corner" with regard to the series' plot lines. On several occasions, she has introduced a new character, but by the time he or she has completed the task of advancing the story or filling in gaps from the past, she has fallen in love with the character or actor. This leads to needless and often destructive changes in the planned story line and/or other characters' basic traits or behavior. In doing so, she is treating her viewers as morons and has bastardized the characters we love. And regarding the season three finale, does the term "Deus ex machina" ring any bells?

Ms. Rhimes states in her blog, "I did my level best to burn it all down this season, to burn it to the ground so that we can have a place to build from next season." Perhaps we can also offer her a word of warning about "burning" Meredith and Derek's relationship with it. That relationship and the onscreen chemistry between Ellen Pompeo and Patrick Dempsey are what first attracted many viewers to this program. Burn them and you cook your goose - the one that lays your golden eggs. And if we are faced with another Meredith/Derek/McWhoever triangle next season, I think we all may have a little McVomit in our mouths. Boring! Been there, done that to death.

If you believe that this letter is the hysterical whimsy of a few disgruntled fans, we would like to refer you to the ABC Grey's Anatomy Writer's Blog comments at www.greyswriters.com/.

In essence, we are asking you to please exert whatever pressure possible on the producers and writers of Grey's Anatomy before they lose the viewers who have made it the number one show on primetime television. We want our uniquely quirky and refreshing television program back, please.”

Update (6/8/2007) - Thanks to an email from one of the people who contributed to the above letter, I now have the source. The above letter was a group-effort, written by some of the posters at ABC’s ‘Grey’s Anatomy’ message board - Specifically, the people who post in the “New Spoilers” thread. – Nice work, guys!

The fans have spoken. Your move, Shonda.

Do you agree that Grey's Anatomy has gone downhill?

Latest Headlines:

Neil Patrick Harris To Host The 2009 Emmys... Maybe

TV Recap: So You Think You Can Dance - Top 14 Results

2009 Summer TV Preview: Great American Road Trip

Star Wars TV Series Filmed Down Under

TV Recap: So You Think You Can Dance - Top 14 Perform

Hillary Duff Joins Gossip Girl

2009 Summer TV Preview: Big Brother 11

Hell's Kitchen Season Six Video Clips

Clips From Zeke And Luther Stars' New Music Video

Stars Reflect On Michael Jackson's Career In TV Guide Network Special

Kelly's Must Have List!

Comment on “Grey's Anatomy Fans Express Their Disapproval (Updated!)”

Note: This website is not meant for use by minors. The views expressed in the comments section below are not our own. This section is intended for discussion of the topic in the post above. Disagreement is encouraged, however comments which attack, insult, or threaten the author in a personal manner won't be published. Similarly, comments that we deem to be poorly worded, or wildly off topic will also not be approved and may be mocked. For free, uncensored, unfettered, and possibly dangerous discussion visit our forum.

Subscribe to topic comments

0 0 / 0
y n

Disgusted
October 27, 2008 at 04:23

I agree that this show has gone down hill quickly. I am most disturbed by the Callie/Ericka relationship and any time either character is on screen, I change the channel. They royally messed up when they left the Mer/Der story line and changed up the characters. But they REALLY, TRULY messed up when they brought in the Cal/Er relationship. Ughhhhhhh! No more Grey's for me!!!!

Reply
0 0 / 0
y n

Carlie
July 31, 2008 at 02:40

I think enough has been said.
We all know now that the show completely sucks now.
I quit watching halfway into the 4th season, and so did my friends.. we're trying to recruit more people, and so far everyone has been willing to spend their thursday nights out, or watching different program.
A sort of, 'Anti Grey's' society thing.. if you will.
Too tired of the crap.. 'Seriously'
Could not take it anymore.
I felt like it was ME that was going to need therapy after watching a show like that.. and I really don't need to have my Friday's completely ruined because I was pissed off about Grey's the night before.

Good luck with what's left of your show shonda (Which is hardly anything).. all though I highly doubt you'll have a spot for grey's anatomy anymore on ABC due to your lowering ratings.

Please, ABC..
find a new show that doesn't want us to tie ropes around our necks and hang from the ceiling fan..

Reply
0 0 / 0
y n

Go Away
April 18, 2008 at 03:31

IW didn't use an unfortunate word. It was the context & what he meant by it. Then he lied. Just imagine someone saying I'm not your nigger or slave. That's what he said in reference to the other actor. The stereotype of being gay & a sissy. IW simply thinks he's someone great. Far from an educated doctor. He's an actor, that's all. He's probably done very little for anyone but himself in his life & obviously if you waste a few moments of his precious time he'll have a few derogatory terms to throw around.

Reply
0 0 / 0
y n

Sheila
March 28, 2008 at 15:59

How about getting ABC to get Dr. Burke back on the show for Season 5 at least. I don't know about others, but I could' ve watched him and also the Burktina couple for season after season after season.

Come on now ABC, I am sure the issue has blown over, as it is it was blown way out of proportion to begin with. Time to heal the wounds, to tie loose ends, get closure by getting (St. Sebastian), the injured mortally wounded, embittered IW back. Time to make wrongs right again. Time to right the grave injustice done to a fine actor, > he did not deserve to lose his livelihood and reputation all in one go! for one wrongful word ?

Dr Burke's role was an asset the show, added character and depth and very fine qualities. Anyway, Dr Burke was also most like doctors in real life are, him and Dr Bailey, are most representative of doctors than any of the rest of the frivolous bunch. The interns are fun but they cannot define the show. IW is a strong actor and having him back on the show may raise it from the slutfest it has become on Season 4, ..gag.

I hope ABC comes to its senses and gets IW back. I am sure he will be only too happy, his best role was as Dr Burke on GA show.

As for the bias, imagine > how would it be if doctors stood up as a group and started the campaign about the way they are depicted? Not always moral, do doctors even get time to have sex on the job?? wow

> How come no group objected to the use of the word 'Nazi' on the show ? Yetttt everyone began to bay for IW's blood coz of one unfortunate word.
I guess the cause to pick... depends on who is getting what from it, def in this case at least !
Bias can be so selective esp if they serve self-gains, what say TRH and KH ?

Reply
0 0 / 0
y n

Sheila
March 28, 2008 at 15:58

How about getting ABC to get Dr. Burke back on the show for Season 5 at least. I don't know about others, but I could've watched him and also the Burktina couple for season after season after season.

Come on now ABC, I am sure the old issue has blown over, as it is it was blown way out of proportion to begin with. Time to heal the wounds, to tie loose ends, get closure by getting (St. Sebastian), the injured, mortally wounded, embittered IW back. Time to make wrongs right again. Time to right the grave injustice done to a fine actor; > he did not deserve to lose his livelihood and reputation all in one go! for one wrongful word ?

Dr Burke's role was an asset the show, added character and depth and very fine qualities. Anyway, Dr Burke was also most like doctors in real life are, him and Dr Bailey, are most representative of doctors than any of the rest of the frivolous bunch. The interns are fun but they cannot define the show. IW is a strong actor and having him back on the show may raise it from the slutfest it has become on Season 4, ....gag.

I hope ABC comes to its senses and gets IW back. I am sure he will be only too happy, his best role was as Dr Burke on GA show.

As for the bias, imagine > how would it be if doctors stood up as a group and started the campaign about the way they are depicted? Not always moral, do doctors even get time to have sex on the job?? wow

> How come no group objected to the use of the word 'Nazi' on the show ? Yetttt everyone began to bay for IW's blood coz of one unfortunate word.
I guess the cause to pick... depends on who is getting what from it, def in this case at least !
Bias can be so selective esp if they serve self-gains, what say TRH and KH ?

Reply
0 0 / 0
y n

Nadine
November 23, 2007 at 10:46

I do agree with the letter, although it is a bit harsh. Season three indeed lacks the thrill and adventure in watching the first two seasons. Izzie is too random and lost, she jumps from "loving" one to another, feeling so passionate towards each one, it is so unrealistic. And the Meredith - Derik chase is really getting old, if the writers don't want them to be together so it would not be a "happily ever after" cliche, that is really not a good idea. Some happiness really should enter Meredith's life, and more maturity and stability into Izzie's life aswell.

Reply
0 0 / 0
y n

Junum
November 23, 2007 at 10:46

The show became too dark and miserable in season three, and I think it really needs to get it's fun spark back by season four. That's what this show is so famous for! Well, that and the passionate relationships never found on any other show.

Reply
0 0 / 0
y n

May
November 23, 2007 at 10:46

Slon really deserves to commit to Allison! And well, yes the letter is harsh but it is true, the show could have been better. I still love Grey's Anatomy but it will be a shame to watch it change. And Burke was such a great character in the show, I believe it would be difficult to fill the gap again in season four. Good Luck...

Reply
0 0 / 0
y n

Beth
September 26, 2007 at 22:31

Honestly, I think that people need to settle down. This is just a T.V. show, not a real-life documentary. I understand that the storyline could be happier and better. However..I think that everyone should give season 4 a try. I know that I'm excited for it, because the end of season 3 was like a cliffhanger..it keeps you wondering and curious. I think its ridiculous that people would actually write a letter to the writers of GA. That's so absurd...leave it be, and wait to see what happens.

Reply
0 0 / 0
y n

Nikki
August 30, 2007 at 15:57

I do not agree with the letter. I am a faithful watcher and fan of Greys Anatomy. I got hook on the first episode and watched ever since and I own both DVD's and I definitley plan on buying the third Season also. Yes there were some story lines that were a little out there but first of all it is entertainment. To make someone want to watch is to have Character do crazy things or act irrational. That is part of life. You cant tell me that there is someone out there that hasnt at least once just went a little nutty from time and again. I know I do and I will admit it. So the realness of the characters is what draws us in and the corky weird things that may happen is what entertains and keeps us watching and guess what will happen next. But over all I think that Shonda Rhimes and her writing staff did a great job. You may of thought it was alittle out there but you watched. You dont get rated the #1 show on prime time for nothing or for bad writing. You get that title with doing things like "Burning it down" Because if we didnt then it would be a Soap Opera with the same freaking story line for 10+ years. Not yes you will always have an underlying issue but you cant keep doing the same thing over and over again or you will definitely lose viewers.

Now I do have to address the issue that the email stated about how Shonda Rhimes said that woman can't have it all. Obviously she didnt listen well enough to the Podcast or she would of realized that she was saying that about everyone. NOT JUST WOMAN. She was saying that it was ironic that One woman has the perfect private life (family and such) and the other has the perfect career. Showing the you could have both. And how that was kind of what the Chief was like because he choose his career over his family life and with Derek telling him to try again and be chief he could do things differently. Now I dont know about you but to me I think that she is setting it up to show that yes most people think that you cant have it all (hence Bailey and Callie) but if you have a second chance what would you do differently and the chief has that.

The next thing that I thought was absolutely ludacris was that because she wrote in infidelity, abortion, and etc that we are losing the value of the show. That is crap. Wake up that is life. People every day are getting married and divorce or there is always going to be people out there that cheat on there significant other. That is life, it has been that way for centuries and I am pretty sure that for years to come and until the end of time there will be at least one person that will cheat on there partner. It is a fact of life hence why it should be in the show. Now I know that topic of Abortion is a touchy subject for most people but it happens. People do have them, whether anyone thinks that it is right or wrong, people do have them and there is nothing that anyone can say that will stop that. so why should it not be taked about. Contraversy is a good thing. It keeps people on there toes and it make you really think for your self and form your own opinion.

But over all I guess what I am trying to say is that I love this show. I will watch it till the day it stops or I die which ever come first. And if it ever were to not be on. Thank god I have the DVD's so I will always be able to watch it. And one last thought and much as everyone is complaining about the show they must be doing something right because if you are using that much energy and talking about it that much you are hook. Because the only time the Shonda Rhimes should worry is if no one is talking about the show then that means that the public has lost interest in the show.

Reply
0 0 / 0
y n

Jessica
August 17, 2007 at 16:47

ehhhh i don't really agree with the letter...probably because i really liked the season 3....not as much as season one and two but still liked it. i was definately left wanting more by the end of season 3 which is really the writers' job. leave them wanting more.

it doesnt have to be bright and shiny to be good. and we all know meredith and derek arent over...they may break up for a little while but theyre not over. them two? one hospital? over? nada. and i personally wouldnt mind another love triangle between them. but thats just me...

i realize know no one on the show was really happy by the end of season 3 finale but no one was really left happy at the end of season two. yea, meredith and derek had sex. hot, dirty, cheating, adulterous sex. i'm not saying i didnt like it. because i did...it was hot...really hot. but also wrong and they knew that. i'm just saying.... quite honestly i have no doubt in my mind that meredith and derek will end up together and stay together by the end of the series finale. theyre like ross and rachel.

and i will definately be buying the season three dvd the day it comes out. =]

Reply
0 0 / 0
y n

Barbara Gram
August 7, 2007 at 16:21

I am a loyal watcher of Greys. Regardless of what everyone says, I will be back. I am so obsessed with the show - its sad - especially for someone as old as I am. It's almost embarassing. However, there were two reasons that I watched the show. The first were the story lines. some were quirky, some were shocking. When a show can leave me speechless at the end and I can't move off my couch to go to bed - that is good writing. I didn't have any of that this season. The second was the relationship between Derek and Meredith. I'm a romantic at heart. I love the boy meets girl gets girl theory. There is so much chemistry between Derek and Meredith that I can't stand it. My heart races when they are together. If only I could meet someone like that and have him look at me the way Derek looks at Meredith. It's my fairy tale.

Each character on the show has his or her own story line. I hated that you had Izzy fall for George. There wasn't any chemistry there. There isn't any chemistry with George and Callie either. I kind of liked when George and the little nurse were together or maybe when you had Christine Ricci as a guest star in Season II. There was more chemistry between her and George the few minutes they were on screen then there is between George/Izzie/Calli.

We all watch TV or go to the movies because we want to be entertained. Because we want to escape from the everyday pressures we are faced with these days.

Bring back my fairy tale and the laughs, tears, and shocks of Season I and II.

Reply
0 0 / 0
y n

shelly
August 3, 2007 at 07:23

I totally agree with the letter also. This season was not good. Season 1 and 2 was great, I have those on DVD. I erased all of season 3 from my DVR.
Why can not Mer/Der be happy, they can still be very interesting. They have chemistry. They have been through there trials. Let them be happy.
Izzy and George I do not even want to go there. She was so in love with Denny. Then overnight she was in love with George?
How come storylines can not be finished. Such as Izzy's daughter, after the one episode we are supposed to forget all the storylines that came in the episode prior to it.
Why have Alex fall in love with a patient, we already went through that with Izzy, that matched her personality, it does not match Alex's.
But two of my main complaints are with MER/DER and Chris/Burke. Mer and Der are the show, people watch because of them. Do not break them up. Christina and Burke were a couple who understood each other. No matter what problems they had they would comprimise until the end. Then to have Burke just leave when he is so dedicated to the hospital and Christina.
Burke needs to come back. Who hasnt said something that they wished they had not. He said he was sorry. I think if he was going to be let go they should have done it right then and not waited until the end of the season. It is like waiting to disipline a child 5 months after the event happened. Bring him back.

Reply
0 0 / 0
y n

Nellie
August 1, 2007 at 11:17

We all fell in love with the characters that you built. That is why we watch the show. To see these people that we have grown to love like our own. Someone posted a comment about it and I agree 100%. Why would we watch a show that has been burned to the ground to get a fresh start. I can easily find a new show with brand new characters to watch, rather than sit and remember how it used to be. I too am a huge fan of Der and Mer could they have one full episode of happiness, rather than a few moments. They are both so depressing now that I want to slit my wrists if they don't. Let them be happy and smile.
Firing I.W. was a mistake. We really don't care what happend backstage, we would be watching reality television if it did. Sometimes people don't get along with co-workers, that's life people, suck it up and do your job.

Reply
0 0 / 0
y n

Susan H
July 16, 2007 at 19:22

I totally agree..the show used to be fun to watch. seasons 1 and 2 I watched the re-runs..I have the DVDs..season 3..I stopped watching during the first runs..recorded and then watched on fast forward to see if Derek and Meredith had any fun scenes together. no such luck ..I will probably record the season opener to see if something good happens but I am not hopeful and I dread how they plan to use this ridiculous half-sister character who is just one year behind Meredith?? the show has really pushed creditability to the limit. If there is no more relationship for Meredith and Derek then I will vote with my remote and tune back into CSI which is what I have been wtaching all summer...

Reply
0 0 / 0
y n

cassgirlnyc0817
June 27, 2007 at 00:07

I was THE #1 GA fan S1 &2. The S2 finaleleft me breathless! Episodes 1 & 2 of S3 were brilliant. They started to loose me at the end of E3 when Mer cut her date w/Der short. E4 was fantastic until Der told Mer to be w/Finn, "the better man". What an insult to the viewers. Most of us watch GA for Mer/Der, and this entire seaon after E4, there were maybe 4 brief moments of happiness for them. Heck, even their happy bath tub scene turned dark. All season, Der and Mer walked around like depressed zombies. Shadows of themselves. George and Izzie had personality transplants, and Mark was way under used. Please save our show!

Reply
0 0 / 0
y n

Trena
June 26, 2007 at 16:49

I've been a fan from the beginning, It's a show that both myself and spouse watch together. Please bring Grey's back look at the votes...it tells the story wake up and get back on track.....Please...

Reply
0 0 / 0
y n

Shannon
June 25, 2007 at 18:47

I can't believe they got rid of Burke. He was probably the best character on the show, with Christina of course. The show has definitely gone down hill, but I will try to watch next season. I don't know how far into the season I can go if things don't improve. I really loved seasons 1 and 2 of Grey's. But, season 3 just wasn't up to par. I really hope the writers and producers make some changes.

Reply
0 0 / 0
y n

Shakia Williams
June 22, 2007 at 17:33

Dear Shonda and Grey's Anatomy Writers,

I have been a loyal Grey's Anatomy fan since the premiere and I love how you guys keep us on the edge of our seat but I do have some complaints.

What in the world is wrong with Ellen Pompeo's character Meredith! I love her and all but she needs to be smacked. I cried with this girl all throughout when we were in pursuit of longing for our McDreamy now she has him and don't know what to do with him! It's like she loved what she couldn't have! How could she walk away from Derek repeatedly when she begged him to choose her over Addison!?

When Meredith was in acoma, Denny showed her how her life impacted all of them including McDreamy.(Oh, we're not suppose to remember that right?) So why would she just break up with him in code like that at the alter of all places! She is making me sick right now.

Christina's life and happiness has nothing to do with hers! Christina and Burke's marriage would give her hope for happiness to be possible for her own life? Why have you made her character so weak? And why do you keep letting people smack her and grip her up without her defending herself. I wanted to jump through my tv screen at Callie!

What happened to my McCouple that I fell in love with!? You people are killing the Grey's Anatomy we all fell in love with! LOL! What is wrong with Christina!? Burke is the best she can get. He is the bomb and madly in love with her! Those wedding vows were the most romantic I have ever heard! The writer who came up with that deserves a raise. Bravo! Good Job!

Please Shonda! Isaiah should not be fired! He is Preston Burke darnnit! Sorry, but the man is phenomenal at his job! I don't care who doesn't like him! Isaiah is a very hardworking and hard-earning individual that deserves this job, do not deprive him of this opportunity over a few words that he has apologized for! He did everything ABC has asked of him! Why are black people punished so unjustly!? Let's be serious, if this was another castmate, like McSteamy, NOTHING I mean NOTHING would be done! It wouldn't have even leaked to the press! If this isn't about race what is it about? One word that has been spurted out in anger, we all say things we don't mean! The punishment does not fit the crime! I do feel Isaiah is being targeted by the media and he is being punished for it and his talented performance for Burke's character is not even being evaluated! His work thus far is going unnoticed!!!

Furthermore, Why doesn't Isaiah have a McName!?!? How is it that McSteamy came on after him and got a McName? Is this a racial issue? Well it can't be because Shonda you are black and you gave them their names right? I don't understand this either, and if I was Isaiah I would have a problem with it too! He could be McCharming or McLoyal, McFaithful, McWonderful, McHandsome, McFoxy, McClassy, or McSomething! I'm sorry but I am on both sides. T.R. is right for feeling put on the spot regarding his lifestyle, and he got the apology publicly so let's move forward. George and Burke were becoming best friends!

Patrick said they are family and families fight! Isaiah apologized, and let's move on with the show. He is Preston Burke! Nobody can fill those shoes! He is the most believable actor/doctor on primetime! Shonda please bring him back, don't let him go!

I heard T.R. Knight didn't renew his contract and he is leaving too! Please let that be a lie. George is a very good actor. I love him and Izzy, don't do this to the George/Izzy fans! I love them! My favorite George line is when he was pretending to be Christina for Meredith and she pretended to be Izzy. He said,"McDreamy did the McNasty with McHotty, that McBastard!" I died laughing. So funny and creative. This is the most creative show since Alley McBeal.

I can't stand Callie, but it's only because she is with George she should be with McSteamy. And because of the crap she put him through. But she's beautiful with the black hair and eyes.

Why did you mess everyone's characters up writers? Poor Alex, all confused and fighting his feelings for Addison/Rebecca/Ava.

The characters are all getting on my nerves, except for Miranda and the Chief. I'm happy for him and his wife Adele and I think Miranda should have been number one choice for Chief but I was sooo happy McDreamy gave the position back to Chief Richard Webber. I love this handsome man, and his loyalty to his wife. The writers did something right bringing them back together.

Alright Season 4 better be better than ever. Not sure what the girl at the end with the last name Grey is all about but it better not involve my McDreamy! Another triangle for this McCouple and I am done!

Lastly please give Chandra "Miranda (The Nazi)" Wilson more spotlight! I love her and I am proud of her strong independent not trying to get in everyone's business attitude but I would like for her to open up more so we can know about her life. And congrats to her for winning the SAG Award, she deserves it because she is the best!

You guys are taking entirely too much from us fans that it is so up in the air regarding tuning in all throughout sesaon 4! First we lost Denny, then Mere's mom, and her step mom (What the heck did she do to deserve that?) I feel her dying was extremely unnecessary! Now we're losing Burke AND George!?!?!? What are you guys doing over there? I disagree as well with your opinion that women can't have it all regarding a career, love and a family. That is your opinion and you are entitled to that but please stop incorporating this through our beloved characters! This is tv, they CAN have it all, dang give us some hope! Let us skip the reality of our bad day and live a better one through them. Look, one of us have to be happy!

Shakia Williams (24) South Philadelphia 19145

Reply
0 0 / 0
y n

brenda
June 22, 2007 at 12:06

I completely agree with the letter. I am a loyal fan, watched every episode (even season 3), I make sure nothing conflicts with Grey's night, but...... I did not enjoy season 3. I really do like all the cast, but the reason I watch the show is Meredith and Derrick. I, like other viewers ,love the chemistry and passion between the two of them. I know real life has disappointment, but sometimes it has forever as well. Season 1 and 2 and some of 3 was all about true love and them working things out, just to burn it all down. Even though it may be narrow minded of me - if they are over - I am over the show.

Reply
0 0 / 0
y n

Ellen
June 20, 2007 at 18:13

I was also not happiest with Season 3. Therefore, I will not buy Season 3 on DVD. I'd much rather watch Season 1 & 2 on DVD during the summer.

I am aslo very unhappy that Isaiah Washington was fired.

Reply
0 0 / 0
y n

Terry
June 15, 2007 at 16:48

There are so many inconsistencies, it is really hard to care anymore.

For me, the most obvious one is the fact that they are bringing in this new character, Lexie, who is supposed to be Meredith's sister. However, somehow this sister (one that must have been born at least 6 years after Meredith) is only a year younger, and decides to take her surgical internship at the same program as Meredith. Apparently this girl began kindergarten while still in her mother's womb.

This is impossible. Do the writers realize that?

Also, before Susan died that ridiculous death, she was trying to get close to Meredith. You would think she would have mentioned the fact that her daughter was coming to the same program as Meredith. It is what any mother would have done in any logical setting. Of course, sloppy writing does not allow for logical progressions. If they bring in some wild, band-aid solution to this obvious inconsistency... a pathetic one such as "Meredith's father had an affair with Susan all along, thus having Lexie the year after Meredith was born... contradicting everything else that has been written about all characters involved)... I swear I will never again watch this show.

Then there is the fact that Lexie meets Derek on the night of her mother's funeral. She shows up at a bar (WHY the bar across from the hospital remains unexplained. It would make sense if it was the bar across from the funeral home or the cemetery, not the hospital... What she drove there after the funeral just for kicks??? Apparently, a daughter who just UNEXPECTEDLY AND SHOCKINGLY loses her mother to the hiccups just goes to a bar, perfectly groomed and without any trace of having cried ever in her life, and tries to pick up men with a warm smile in her face... What are these characters not human anymore? What happened to the rich, complex characters we used to enjoy..., like Bailey? Are we now introducing the "bad, heartless girl"... like in some cheap Mexican soap opera? So we are supposed to believe this girl is fine on the night of her mother's funeral, and that she calls her mother's death "having a bad day"? I find it offensive to the intelligence of the viewers of this show.

I think the writers have lost all respect for us. They really do believe we just swallow anything and everything. No matter how stupid or unbelievable.
It is a real shame. Someone should tell them about cable, other channels, other networks, NetFlick... lots of other options we have at our disposal. Do they honestly believe people will stick around for this crap?

Reply
0 0 / 0
y n

Memphis
June 15, 2007 at 10:02

I agree that it would be a waste if they break up Meredith and Derrik with Meredith's sister. I would stop watching the show if they did that!

Reply
0 0 / 0
y n

Jody Hughes
June 15, 2007 at 00:06

I think Isaiah Washington needs to return as Burke. If not, I will not be watching and I think I speak for a lot of people when I say that!

Reply
0 0 / 0
y n

Tristan
June 14, 2007 at 22:54

I definitely agree with this! I was not happy at all with season three and was very disappointed because this is the only show that i actually make time to watch. The whole Meredith and McDreamy deal was good at first, but if they try it again it is just going to be way too much. They need to leave them to rest and go about something else for next season. Their relationship during this season changed so much from one episode to the next that it seemed so completely untrue. Derek does not act like his kind caring soul almost the entire half of season three , and then to try and bring in Meredith's sister, Lexi, to break them apart next season! Not cool!!!

They completely changed the charisma of so many of the characters last season that I can't even imagine what is going to happen next season with them. Burke would never just give up and take off like that. He is too focused and in love with his job, and himself, to walk out on that hospitol. These characters started out so headstrong and focused, and they would not let these petty nonsense things get to them. But now they are all...broken.

Another thing is, even though I do think the new series with Addison in LA might actually be pretty good, I will not at all be happy if Addison leaves Grey's Anatomy! She did a great job of making her way through the show and turning to the good side, that she needs to stay. She needs to stay on the show and get McSteamy!! Alex is taken! ;o)

Well, I am very interested, and intensely waiting to see what is going to happen next season. To see if my favorite show will survive or if it will be ruined! Honestly, something needs to change next season or this show is going to end, and there will be so many devastated hearts out there.

Reply

Pages: 1 2 3

Subscribe to topic comments

Please login or sign up to post reply

Back to Grey's Anatomy Fans Express Their Disapproval (Updated!)

Grey's Anatomy Fans Express Their Disapproval (Updated!)

Comment on “Grey's Anatomy Fans Express Their Disapproval (Updated!)”

Leave a Reply