Subscribe To Why Patrick Stewart First Passed On Playing Professor X In X-Men Updates
  • Why Patrick Stewart First Passed On Playing Professor X In X-Men details

Why Patrick Stewart First Passed On Playing Professor X In X-Men Synopsis

Few comic book movie actors will ever match the iconography of Patrick Stewart as Charles Xavier. Ever since the first X-Men hit theaters back in 2000, he has grounded the franchise and provided a sense of gravitas that no actor has managed to match -- not even Hugh Jackman as Wolverine. Stewart's contribution to the success of the X-Men franchise cannot be understated, but it turns out that he almost turned down the role because of the perceived similarities to his role as Star Trek: The Next Generation's Jean-Luc Picard. Stewart explained:

I met with Bryan Singer, who directed the first two movies, and he pitched the idea to me. And I was flattered because I admired his work very, very much and wanted to work with him, but I said, 'You know, it's not very long since I finished work on another franchise...it's all been marvelous, but there is also a downside to becoming so identified with one character.' A director had just said to me, 'I love your work, you're terrific, but why would I want Jean-Luc Picard in my movie?' Well that was discouraging, and I explained this to Bryan and said, 'So I'm going to say thank you, but it's passed.'

Patrick Stewart recently sat down for an interview with MTV alongside Hugh Jackman and admitted that he had some trepidations about playing Charles Xavier back in 2000. He worried that the role would read far too similar to his portrayal of Enterprise Captain Jean-Luc Picard from Star Trek: The Next Generation, and the possibility of becoming "pigeon holed" concerned him. Eventually, Bryan Singer was able to explain his angle for the X-Men universe and how it differed from other sci-fi universes, and the rest is pretty much history.

Patrick Stewart Professor X Logan X-Men
Patrick Stewart Jean Luc Picard Star Trek

That said, Patrick Stewart went on to admit that the X-Men franchise does share one critical similarity with the Star Trek franchise. These two properties -- for all of their high concept, ridiculous premises -- are "about something," and that's what sold Stewart on whether or not to take the part of Charles Xavier. Let that be a lesson to future filmmakers: substance matters just as much as style when you want to attract A-list talent to a given project.

Of course, it's worth mentioning that Patrick Stewart may not be quite as finished with this iconic role as we had previously thought. Although he seems relatively content to finish his tenure as Charles Xavier after Logan, there is one very specific caveat that would get him to stay on as the character. All it would require is for 20th Century Fox to include his version of Professor X in a future Deadpool movie. Who knows? Maybe this would even allow him to finally respond to Wade Wilson's (Ryan Reynolds) comments that he is a "Heaven's Gate looking mother fucker." Considering Patrick Stewart's proven comedic chops, that would seriously be a treat.

Logan opens in theaters today.

For a better look at Patrick Stewart's (seemingly) final outing as Professor X, check out a trailer for Logan on the next page!

Latest Why Patrick Stewart First Passed On Playing Professor X In X-Men News

X-Men's Wolverine: 5 Actors Perfect For The Role In The Inevitable MCU Reboot X-Men's Wolverine: 5 Actors Perfect For The Role In The Inevitable MCU Reboot

Who should play Wolverine in the inevitable MCU recasting? Let's explore some of the talented actors who might have the chops to grow out their mutton chops sideburns, don the adamantium claws and play the popular comic book role.

X-Men's Wolverine: 5 Actors Perfect For The Role In The Inevitable MCU Reboot

New MCU Rumors About Professor X and Magneto Have Marvel Fans Worked Up New MCU Rumors About Professor X and Magneto Have Marvel Fans Worked Up

Will Magneto and Professor X be people of color in the MCU?

New MCU Rumors About Professor X and Magneto Have Marvel Fans Worked Up

Watch Iron Man's Amazing Alternate Ending, As Kevin Feige Announces New MCU Box Set Watch Iron Man's Amazing Alternate Ending, As Kevin Feige Announces New MCU Box Set

Kevin Feige really is a mastermind....

Watch Iron Man's Amazing Alternate Ending, As Kevin Feige Announces New MCU Box Set

6 X-Men The Fox Franchise Didn't Do Justice 6 X-Men The Fox Franchise Didn't Do Justice

Here's some of the mutants that Fox did a real disservice to during its tenure.

6 X-Men The Fox Franchise Didn't Do Justice

Upcoming Marvel Movies: Release Dates For Phase 4 And 5 Upcoming Marvel Movies: Release Dates For Phase 4 And 5

The Marvel Cinematic Universe has big plans for the future. To keep it all straight, we've laid out the next few years' worth of Marvel Studios films in this feature, which will take you through all of the official titles announced for Phase 4 - as well as the unscheduled projects that are currently in development.

Upcoming Marvel Movies: Release Dates For Phase 4 And 5

X-Men Comic Book Writer Says Dark Phoenix Was 'Way Better' Than The Last Stand X-Men Comic Book Writer Says Dark Phoenix Was 'Way Better' Than The Last Stand

Chris Claremont liked Dark Phoenix a lot more than he liked X-Men: The Last Stand.

X-Men Comic Book Writer Says Dark Phoenix Was 'Way Better' Than The Last Stand

Dark Phoenix Officially Ends Run As Lowest-Grossing X-Men Movie: Disney Marketing (Partly) To Blame? Dark Phoenix Officially Ends Run As Lowest-Grossing X-Men Movie: Disney Marketing (Partly) To Blame?

Now that the theatrical run is over, let's assess the damage.

Dark Phoenix Officially Ends Run As Lowest-Grossing X-Men Movie: Disney Marketing (Partly) To Blame?

Why Marvel Should Take Its Time Introducing The X-Men To The MCU Why Marvel Should Take Its Time Introducing The X-Men To The MCU

It's no easy task bringing the X-Men into the MCU. Here are the reasons why Marvel should take their time before they bring this ensemble into the expansive cinematic universe.

Why Marvel Should Take Its Time Introducing The X-Men To The MCU

Disney Is Reportedly ‘Unimpressed’ With The New Mutants Disney Is Reportedly ‘Unimpressed’ With The New Mutants

Uh oh.

Disney Is Reportedly ‘Unimpressed’ With The New Mutants

Marvel’s Kevin Feige Wanted Tony Stark’s Death In Endgame To Be Just As Impactful As Logan Marvel’s Kevin Feige Wanted Tony Stark’s Death In Endgame To Be Just As Impactful As Logan

Both movies bid farewell to superheroes audiences had watched in action for a long time.

Marvel’s Kevin Feige Wanted Tony Stark’s Death In Endgame To Be Just As Impactful As Logan

X-Men First Class Writer Wants Giancarlo Esposito For Marvel’s Magneto X-Men First Class Writer Wants Giancarlo Esposito For Marvel’s Magneto

He definitely knows how to play a villain.

X-Men First Class Writer Wants Giancarlo Esposito For Marvel’s Magneto

6 Times The X-Men Movies Messed Up Its Continuity 6 Times The X-Men Movies Messed Up Its Continuity

The X-Men movies can be great, but the franchise has definitely messed with continuity over time. We explore these problems.

6 Times The X-Men Movies Messed Up Its Continuity

How The Avengers Would've Handled X-Men’s Dark Phoenix How The Avengers Would've Handled X-Men’s Dark Phoenix

A battle so big, it should be a movie! Or two!

How The Avengers Would've Handled X-Men’s Dark Phoenix

The Marvel Movies We'll Probably See In Marvel's Phase 5 The Marvel Movies We'll Probably See In Marvel's Phase 5

We just found out the Marvel Cinematic Universe's Phase 4 slate, but we may actually already know quite a bit about what comes after that.

The Marvel Movies We'll Probably See In Marvel's Phase 5

Kevin Feige Hints Marvel Phase 5 Will Bring In X-Men And Fantastic Four Kevin Feige Hints Marvel Phase 5 Will Bring In X-Men And Fantastic Four

MCU architect Kevin Feige added more teases for X-Men and Fantastic Four.

Kevin Feige Hints Marvel Phase 5 Will Bring In X-Men And Fantastic Four

Dark Phoenix Is Being Rebranded For Its Home Release Dark Phoenix Is Being Rebranded For Its Home Release

Maybe this will help?

Dark Phoenix Is Being Rebranded For Its Home Release

Dark Phoenix Set To End Run A Bigger Box Office Bomb Than Fantastic Four Dark Phoenix Set To End Run A Bigger Box Office Bomb Than Fantastic Four

An unfortunate (human) torch has been passed.

Dark Phoenix Set To End Run A Bigger Box Office Bomb Than Fantastic Four

Russell Crowe Says ‘There’s No Way’ He Could Have Played Wolverine Like Hugh Jackman Russell Crowe Says ‘There’s No Way’ He Could Have Played Wolverine Like Hugh Jackman

What could have been...

Russell Crowe Says ‘There’s No Way’ He Could Have Played Wolverine Like Hugh Jackman

14 Fictional Movie Locations We'd Love To Visit 14 Fictional Movie Locations We'd Love To Visit

You've got a round trip ticket into the magical world of the movies, so where are you going?

14 Fictional Movie Locations We'd Love To Visit

Why Are So Many Of The X-Men Blue? Why Are So Many Of The X-Men Blue?

This is a common color for the X-Men property. Here's why.

Why Are So Many Of The X-Men Blue?

Dark Phoenix Producer Hasn’t Seen The Movie Either Dark Phoenix Producer Hasn’t Seen The Movie Either

Sometimes you just lose track of time.

Dark Phoenix Producer Hasn’t Seen The Movie Either

Yes, Kevin Feige Has Been Thinking About How Marvel Will Bring Mutants To The MCU Yes, Kevin Feige Has Been Thinking About How Marvel Will Bring Mutants To The MCU

What a relief.

Yes, Kevin Feige Has Been Thinking About How Marvel Will Bring Mutants To The MCU

Dark Phoenix Had The Biggest Second Week Drop Of Any Superhero Movie Dark Phoenix Had The Biggest Second Week Drop Of Any Superhero Movie

But hey, this is good news for Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice! It no longer owns that title.

Dark Phoenix Had The Biggest Second Week Drop Of Any Superhero Movie

Beast Could Have Gotten His Own X-Men Spinoff Beast Could Have Gotten His Own X-Men Spinoff

Oh, what could have been.

Beast Could Have Gotten His Own X-Men Spinoff

For Real, X-Men: Days Of Future Past Was A Better Conclusion Than Dark Phoenix For Real, X-Men: Days Of Future Past Was A Better Conclusion Than Dark Phoenix

The X-Men franchise would have more gracefully concluded in 2014. Let's travel back in time and remember why.

For Real, X-Men: Days Of Future Past Was A Better Conclusion Than Dark Phoenix

Dark Phoenix Was Actually Inspired By The Dark Knight Trilogy Dark Phoenix Was Actually Inspired By The Dark Knight Trilogy

Simon Kinberg took inspiration from within the genre for Dark Phoenix.

Dark Phoenix Was Actually Inspired By The Dark Knight Trilogy

7 Times The X-Men Franchise Actually Did Something Awesome 7 Times The X-Men Franchise Actually Did Something Awesome

The X-Men movies had a lot of problems, but it wasn't all bad.

7 Times The X-Men Franchise Actually Did Something Awesome

How Dark Phoenix Totally Changed My Mind About The X-Men And Marvel Cinematic Universe Merger How Dark Phoenix Totally Changed My Mind About The X-Men And Marvel Cinematic Universe Merger

I used to want to see a straight franchise merger with both continuities left in tact. Not anymore.

How Dark Phoenix Totally Changed My Mind About The X-Men And Marvel Cinematic Universe Merger

Original Dark Phoenix Ending Included Skrulls And A 'Huge' New York Battle, According To Tye Sheridan Original Dark Phoenix Ending Included Skrulls And A 'Huge' New York Battle, According To Tye Sheridan

Sounds pretty awesome!

Original Dark Phoenix Ending Included Skrulls And A 'Huge' New York Battle, According To Tye Sheridan

How Dark Phoenix Got That Cool X-Men Comic Cameo Into The Movie How Dark Phoenix Got That Cool X-Men Comic Cameo Into The Movie

X-Men fans have been wanting to see this character in live-action for a while.

How Dark Phoenix Got That Cool X-Men Comic Cameo Into The Movie

 

Related

Patrick Stewart Thinks Picard Might 'Shock' Star Trek Fans
X-Men's Wolverine: 5 Actors Perfect For The Role In The Inevitable MCU Reboot
New MCU Rumors About Professor X and Magneto Have Marvel Fans Worked Up

Hot Topics

New Reviews

Between Two Ferns: The Movie Review: Spurts Of Hilarity Make It Work Just Well Enough
Rambo: Last Blood Review - A Dismal, Dreary, And Unnecessary Sequel
Ad Astra Review: James Gray's Heart Of Darkness In Space Is Gorgeous And Deep

Previews

Detective Pikachu
John Wick: Chapter 3 - Parabellum
Us
Cookie Settings