Skip to main content

Oscar Eye: Predicting The Winners In A Four-Way Race

Last week, after I had written my Oscar Eye column, a flurry of speculation got going after Star Trek and District 9 pulled off surprise nominations from the Producers Guild. Some were predicting Neill Blomkamp or even J.J Abrams as a surprise Directors Guild nominee. Not to mention that Up became the first animated film to be nominated by the producers as both Best Feature and Best Animated Feature, which quieted some of the skeptics about the movie's Oscar chances. Suddenly change in the race seemed possible.

And then the DGA announced their five nominees for Best Director, and the status quo settled back in. The list of Kathryn Bigelow, James Cameron, Lee Daniels, Jason Reitman and Quentin Tarantino isn't bad by any means, but it's exactly what 90% of Oscar watchers would have predicted, give or take Clint Eastwood. In years with five Best Picture nominees, the DGA's choices for directors have matched very, very closely to the Academy's choices of picture-- meaning if you yourself are nominated for a DGA, your film is practically guaranteed a spot on Oscar's list. With 10 nominees this year, and these five directors and their films widely expected to fill in one of those slots, it seems half the roster is already settled.

While some questions remain about the other five films in the line-up-- what will replace Nine? Whither A Serious Man? Can The Blind Side seriously get a Best Picture nomination?-- it seems impossible that any film other than those represented by the DGA's picks will win Best Picture. And while Kathryn Bigelow seems to have the Best Director statue fairly locked down, it seems to be a genuine four-way race for Best Picture (sorry, Precious, but it's just not your year). So a little less than a month before Oscar announces the actual nominees, and a week before the Golden Globes might potentially shed some light on this situation, I'm going to make some actual predictions about winners for the first time, in an admittedly glib and off-the-cuff way (any of this could change tomorrow). God help me.

(Note: The Writers Guild announced their nominees today, but given that a whole host of crazy eligibility rules have shut out some really worthy contenders-- read more here-- I don't really know how to factor the WGA's choices into my predictions. So I'm leaving them out for now).

If Best Picture is truly a four-way race...

The Hurt Locker

Pros: Slew of critic's and guild awards; publicity from Kathryn Bigelow's real shot at being the first-ever female Best Director; passionate support from many could outweigh those who haven't managed to see it.

Cons: It made very little money in theatrical release; it's not exactly a movie for everyone; people still don't really want to talk about Iraq.

Shot at a win: 35%. All it needs is one big populist boost (maybe strong DVD sales?) before it feels like a solid frontrunner.


Pros: Gigantic success; return to old-fashioned moviemaking; employed a huge amount of people; ratings bonanza.

Cons: Even its fans admits it has flaws; James Cameron already won a ton of Oscars; the Academy historically hates sci-fi.

Shot at a win: 30%. If it keeps making money and does well at the Globes, it could be the frontrunner.

Inglourious Basterds

Pros: Financial and critical hit; Quentin Tarantino is a lot more lovable now than he used to be; tons of great performances for actors (the largest Academy branch) to get behind.

Cons: Flawed in places; historical revisionism doesn't go down easy with the olds; Quentin Tarantino isn't exactly as lovable as he could be.

Shot at a win: 18%. Either of the top two would need to stumble in some way before it could take the lead, but a surprise win will seem possible up until Oscar night.

Up in the Air

Pros: Clooney; great performances all around; timely topic; by far the most accessible of the four films.

Cons: Not as smart as it would like to be; fades quickly after impressive first viewings; Reitman is still really young.

Shot at a win: 17%. This percentage feels low, but the movie seems to have peaked early as The Hurt Locker became the critical favorite and the box office success never materialized.

Now on to the charts, where not much has changed because there hasn't been much noise in the acting categories either way. The Golden Globes on Sunday will seem like they're shedding light, though only time will tell how useful those crazy awards are in the end.

oscar winner prediction


Given the PGA nomination, it's entirely possible now that District 9 could jump into that 10th spot-- maybe even more possible than The Blind Side pulling it off. At this point it's the only surprise we probably have in store. I've moved Basterds into the Mortal Lock position given the DGA nomination; now we have six, with An Education and Invictus as 90% certainties. The other two spots may prove to be the most interesting and speculated-upon as the weeks go on. When The Last Station finally opens properly on January 15 it may jump into a contender position too.

oscar winner prediction


The Hurt Locker

Inglourious Basterds

Precious: Based on the Novel 'Push' By Sapphire


Up in the Air

oscar winner prediction

An Education



A Serious Man

oscar winner prediction

The Blind Side


Julie & Julia

The Last Station

A Single Man

The Road

oscar winner prediction

500 Days of Summer

Bright Star


Crazy Heart

The Hangover

The Informant!

Public Enemies

Sherlock Holmes

Star Trek

Where the Wild Things Are

oscar winner prediction


Tarantino, that sly dog, has made it in as a Mortal Lock, making four spots in this category pretty much settled and the fifth likely a slugfest between Lee Daniels and Clint Eastwood. The Coens feel like possibly surprises, but without a possible win on the horizon, it's hugely unlikely.

oscar winner prediction

Kathryn Bigelow, The Hurt Locker

James Cameron, Avatar

Jason Reitman, Up in the Air

Quentin Tarantino, Inglourious Basterds

oscar winner prediction

Joel and Ethan Coen, A Serious Man

Lee Daniels, Precious

Clint Eastwood, Invictus

Rob Marshall, Nine

oscar winner prediction

Jane Campion, Bright Star

Tom Ford, A Single Man

Lone Scherfig, An Education

oscar winner prediction

John Hillcoat, The Road

Michael Hoffman, The Last Station

Michael Mann, Public Enemies

Oren Moverman, The Messenger

Jim Sheridan, Brothers

oscar winner prediction


No movement here at all, not even anyone threatening Bridges' spot on top. Clooney is now feeling even more like a mortal lock, so I'm tossing him in there, but both Freeman and Renner could be replaced in some strange turn of the universe. This is what we call hedging our bets.

oscar winner prediction

Jeff Bridges, Crazy Heart

George Clooney, Up in the Air

Colin Firth, A Single Man

oscar winner prediction

Daniel Day-Lewis, Nine

Morgan Freeman, Invictus

Viggo Mortensen, The Road

Jeremy Renner, The Hurt Locker

Michael Stuhlbarg, A Serious Man

oscar winner prediction

Matt Damon, The Informant!

Joseph Gordon-Levitt, 500 Days of Summer

Tobey Maguire, Brothers

James McAvoy, The Last Station

Sam Rockwell, Moon

oscar winner prediction

Sharlto Copley, District 9

Johnny Depp, Public Enemies

Ben Foster, The Messenger

Hal Holbrook, That Evening Sun

oscar winner prediction


The Last Station finally comes out properly on January 15, but only if it performs abominably will it affect Mirren's chances at a nomination one way or another. Only that or some kind of crazy last-minute surge from Tilda Swinton could potentially shake this up.

oscar winner prediction

Carey Mulligan, An Education

Meryl Streep, Julie & Julia

Gabourey Sidibe, Precious

oscar winner prediction

Sandra Bullock, The Blind Side

Marion Cotillard, Nine

Abbie Cornish, Bright Star

Helen Mirren, The Last Station

oscar winner prediction

Tilda Swinton, Julia

oscar winner prediction

Natalie Portman, Brothers

Saiorse Ronan, The Lovely Bones

oscar winner prediction


Some people think Christoph Waltz isn't guaranteed the statue, and that might be true, but it's still remarkably hard to come up with anyone who's got a nomination so secured. Plummer hasn't managed to get nominated yet, so who knows what will happen; Damon is completely mediocre in a mediocre movie; and Tucci is still looking for a nomination from two different movies, one of which has pretty much self-destructed. Could Paul Schneider, Alfred Molina or Anthony Mackie work their way in there? I have no evidence to say it'll happen, but not much would surprise me in this category at this point.

oscar winner prediction

Christoph Waltz, Inglourious Basterds

oscar winner prediction

Matt Damon, Invictus

Woody Harrelson, The Messenger

Alfred Molina, An Education

Christopher Plummer, The Last Station

Peter Sarsgaard, An Education

Stanley Tucci, Julie & Julia

oscar winner prediction

Richard Kind, A Serious Man

Anthony Mackie, The Hurt Locker

Paul Schneider, Bright Star

Stanley Tucci, The Lovely Bones

oscar winner prediction

Alec Baldwin, It's Complicated

oscar winner prediction


We've gone too long with Mo'nique ruling the Mortal Lock category entirely because no one else is winning anything, and I think at this point Vera Farmiga and Anna Kendrick are pretty much both guaranteed nominations. My crazy Marion Cotillard prediction stands entirely because I don't know what else to do; Penelope Cruz still just feels wrong to me.

oscar winner prediction

Mo'Nique, Precious

Vera Farmiga, Up in the Air

Anna Kendrick, Up in the Air

oscar winner prediction

Penelope Cruz, Nine

Julianne Moore, A Single Man

oscar winner prediction

Mariah Carey, Precious

Marion Cotillard, Nine

Maggie Gyllenhaal, Crazy Heart

Samantha Morton, The Messenger

oscar winner prediction

Diane Kruger, Inglourious Basterds

Melanie Laurent, Inglourious Basterds

Paula Patton, Precious

Staff Writer at CinemaBlend