Fountain Of Youth Is A Fun Movie, But I Don't Think It's Going To Be The Franchise It Seems To Think It Could Be

Natalie Portman on the left looking at John Krasinski, who is wearing a straw hat, on the right.
(Image credit: Apple TV+)

I’m not going to take apart Fountain Of Youth, the latest in the 2025 movie schedule that you can check out with your AppleTV+ subscription. I do think it’s a fun movie, in a “movie of the week” kind of way. I love that the movie is at least trying to be something new and not relying on existing IP, something Hollywood doesn’t take enough chances on these days. The Guy Richie film delivers in being an enjoyable adventure movie perfect for a Sunday afternoon. It also tries to set itself up for a sequel, or even a franchise, and on that front, I’m not so sure it works.

John Krasinski looking stunned while walking in a cavern in Fountain of Youth

(Image credit: Apple TV+)

Fountain Of Youth Seems To Be Inventing The Next Indiana Jones

John Krasinski and Natalie Portman star as brother and sister Luke and Charlotte Purdue, the children of a famed, late archaeologist. Luke is the charming adventurer in the family, going so far as to commit daring art heists to find the clues he is looking for to discover the mythical Fountain of Youth. Charlotte is the more pragmatic sibling, working as a curator in an art museum that Luke burglarizes.

Luke eventually convinces Charlotte to join him in his quest, and the adventure begins in full. I won’t get into too many spoilers here, but the movie trots along at a decent clip, with some completely unrealistic things happening to get to the answers they seek, very much akin to some of Indiana Jones’ adventures, especially from the last couple of movies (not a ringing endorsement, I know). Throw in a dash of The Da Vinci Code’s faux intellectualism, and it seems clear that Richie and Co. are hoping to build a franchise.

John Krasinski on the left, talking to Natalie Portman in Fountain Of Youth

(Image credit: Apple TV+)

The Ending Of Fountain Of Youth Is Especially Heavy-Handed

Once the adventure is over and our heroes have saved the day by making the correct moral decision, and the villain, played Domhnall Gleeson, who is given far too little to do here, is vanquished, Charlotte and Luke have a back and forth that is about as subtle as a lost ark to the head.

Charlotte is ready to team up with her brother again to seek other lost treasures. They trade friendly barbs about what they could look for next, while giving no answers (and the cast isn’t letting on, either, about a potential sequel). There are, of course, dozens of potential artifacts or mythical places to search out in a franchise. That doesn’t mean there will be one, though.

From left to right: Eiza González, John Krasinski and Natalie Portman all standing in The Fountain of Youth in front of the pyramids.

(Image credit: Apple TV+)

Fountain Of Youth Just Isn’t Strong Enough To Launch A Franchise

Krasinski is great in the movie, and he’s much more realistic as a reluctant action hero than, say, as Jack Ryan in the Amazon show of the same name, which he starred in. Portman is, as always, great, but something doesn’t work here. The dialogue is a little cheesy, and the plot, while a great idea, doesn’t hold together. There is no villain that we know of until the end, and even that feels forced, despite Charlotte’s foreshadowing.

Then there is the sort of ham-fisted dialogue at the end, trying to set up a sequel. It’s all just a little too presumptive and, frankly, cheesy, the way they do it. Sure, movies have long set up franchises and sequels, but usually that’s once they are established. Fountain of Youth isn’t there yet. I’d be all for giving the characters one more chance, but will audiences and Apple agree? I just don’t know.

Hugh Scott
Syndication Editor

Hugh Scott is the Syndication Editor for CinemaBlend. Before CinemaBlend, he was the managing editor for Suggest.com and Gossipcop.com, covering celebrity news and debunking false gossip. He has been in the publishing industry for almost two decades, covering pop culture – movies and TV shows, especially – with a keen interest and love for Gen X culture, the older influences on it, and what it has since inspired. He graduated from Boston University with a degree in Political Science but cured himself of the desire to be a politician almost immediately after graduation.

You must confirm your public display name before commenting

Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.