Leave a Comment
Gotham's expansive rogues gallery has been on full display in Season 5, which has brought back just about every noteworthy villain that didn't experience an irreversible death. It looks like those who faced reversible deaths are more than welcome to return though, as Gotham revealed Andrew Sellon's previously murdered Mr. Penn will be returning soon as the sadistic villain The Ventriloquist, complete with the deadly dummy Scarface.
First, let's take a moment to revel in the wonder and glory that is Gotham for being the kind of show that can drop a big Ventriloquist shocker without anyone questioning whether the villain is too cartoonish or not. Granted, most of the DC shows out there eschew realism in the name of spectacle, but a homicidal dummy would probably only work on Gotham and maybe Legends of Tomorrow. (Both shows have featured Paul Reubens as guest stars, which I choose not to think of as a coincidence.)
Next, let's all wag a bemusedly judgmental finger at Gotham showrunner John Stephens, who made comments last year pegging Ventriloquist and Scarface as characters that the creative team fought to work into the story, only to have to leave them both behind for narrative reasons. Of course, lots of things that comic book TV showrunners say should always be viewed as suspicious, but it's completely believable that The Ventriloquist might be a little too heightened for last-minute inclusions.
Note that John Stephens likely wasn't purposefully lying about having to avoid using Ventriloquist. At the time he was making those comments, Fox hadn't yet ordered the additional two episodes that bring Season 5's total to twelve. So it can be presumed that those extra installments provided just the extra time needed for everyone to say hello to Ventriloquist's little friend.
The writers apparently figured out a way to not only bring in the one Batman villain who would destroy on America's Got Talent, but also to tie that introduction back to one of Season 5's big deaths. In "Penguin, Our Hero," the dutiful accountant Mr. Penn was killed by angered gang members, and he died in Penguins arms after telling his former boss that everyone hated him. Kind of a fitting end, even if it wasn't a permanent one.
Just in case anyone thought that Mr. Penn would be coming back from the grave without crossing paths with Oswald Cobblepot, think again.
Titans fans will recall that Ventriloquist and Scarface technically did show up in that show's Season 1 finale, but the complicated story details made the appearance less legitimate than expected. So Gotham will feature the first official live-action take on The Ventriloquist, which is about as awesome as can be.
First introduced in 1988, The Ventriloquist has been the deadly alter ego for three different comic book characters, though none of them were Arthur Penn. As such, it's hard to tell whether or not Gotham will even try to match Andrew Sellon's villain up with one from the source material.