From the trailers you might think Happy Feet is a rather silly kids' movie about happy little penguins dancing and singing. It's not. Happy Feet is a true epic. It's Lord of the Rings with flippers. Star Wars with fish. The Lion King with flightless birds instead of predators. A few early reviews from more politically charged writers have rather bizarrely started labeling it as liberal propaganda, but the politically motivated out there are always looking for a reason to stir up red state versus blue state controversy. Yes the movie gets way too preachy in the final act, but there's nothing truly subversive here. Happy Feet is a surprisingly well crafted, grand-scale, heroic adventure. Dismissing it as dancing penguins or Al Gore environmentalism run amok is unfair. It contains bits of both, but as a whole it is neither.
The movie is the first attempt at animation from Mad Max director George Miller, and he doesn't waste a single frame. He takes what might have been a rather simple story of an outsider finding a way to fit in and turns it into a grand and beautiful work of cinematic art. I'm not just talking visuals here, though there's no denying this is absolutely the most stunning computer animated movie ever done by anyone outside of Pixar. It's the story too. This thing is borderline as a kids' movie, it tackles some pretty heavy themes and goes places that not all kids will be able to follow. They'll be wowed by the animation, but the heart of Happy Feet is something so deep and soulful that at least part of it is aimed squarely at adults. Miller's movie goes way beyond the standard kids' movie lessons of family, friends, and acceptance to tread places most pre-teen targeted movies are afraid to go.
That's not to say Happy Feet is all doom and gloom. This is a joyous, celebratory movie. In telling the story of a young penguin named Mumbles, the film celebrates penguin life and fills itself to the brim with breathtaking sequences showing off the world from a birds' eye view. But there's more.
Mumbles is still fresh out of the shell when his parents find out he has a problem. He can't sing. Singing is what defines an Emperor penguin. They call it their "heart song", and it's the unique sound each penguin makes to attract a mate or identify his or her self to partners and kids. To us it sounds like a lot of squawking, but to them it's perfectly performed, toe-tapping pop songs. Each penguin has his own style, and without a song Mumbles has no future.
Mumbles can't sing, but he can do something no other penguin can do: He can dance. When his waddling buddies let out the feelings in their heart through song, Mumbles gets happy feet. He can't control it. Just as music is the audible manifestation of who each penguin is, dancing is a physical expression of what's in Mumbles' soul. There's never been a bird like Mumbles, and the other penguins fear him. He's an outcast, and the first half of the movie follows the struggle of Mumbles and his parents as he tries to deal with that. It's not easy.
The second half takes Mumbles on a massive journey across Antarctica to prove his societal worth. Epic is really the only way to describe it. If the first half of the movie is Tatooine then the second half is Mumbles' Death Star run. Miller doesn't settle just for large-scale adventure though, the movie is packed with thematic depth and complexity beyond the ken of this relatively short review to describe. Happy Feet has layers, of the kind you're not going to find in most of the bargain bin kiddie movies probably already on top of your TV set.
Where some people are taking issue with it, is in the movie's final act. The film takes an almost manic environmentalist stance, with Mumble's dancing somehow changing the human world and saving his clan from starvation caused by over-fishing. It starts out well done, and that first moment where Mumbles steps out of the blinding snow and spots his first sign of human habitation is breathtaking. Miller does a stunning job of tying it all together while showing the world from a tiny penguin's viewpoint. He sets his camera to give you a real sense of scale. The human world looks so massive by comparison, for instance a shot out the window of an abandoned shack as Mumbles waddles past hits home how fragile the little guy is. Because of that the movie has impact; it delivers something bigger than the average talking animal flick.
But the messages do get to be a bit much. By its end the movie is a rush of Important Consequences, so much so that the smaller, much more critical (from a character standpoint) reunion and reunification of the relationship between Mumbles and his father Memphis is overshadowed. I love the way Miller turns such a simple throw-pillow of a plot into a vivid epic, but after doing that the movie should have wound down and gotten back in touch with the smaller moments that he used to build towards that large-scale journey the movie becomes.
I'm not sure how many people will actually notice the movie's preachy ending. By then you're so wrapped up in the characters, their quest, and the film's breathtaking visual flair that a wild but brief cacophony of exhortative information may go wholly unnoticed. Crazy zealotism and environmental irresponsibility bad; clear thinking and respect for Mother Nature good. Alright, whatever. Those aren't such bad lessons for kids to learn, I remember getting much the same ideas from Ranger Rick as a lad. If you're seeing anything more sinister than that in Happy Feet, it's because you're going looking for it. We complain a lot about how shallow kids' movies often are, but when something with heft comes along it's labeled as propaganda. This is an excellent animated movie, one with great performances and a vision so strong that it deserves to be mentioned right up there with the best of the now comfortably familiar computer animated medium. There's nothing comfortable about Happy Feet. It's brave and heartfelt, a surprising cinematic accomplishment.
Note: This website is not intended for use by minors. The views expressed in this comments section are not necessarily our own. Comments that we deem to be poorly worded, off topic, or threatening will not be published. For free, uncensored discussion visit our forum.
"A few early reviews from more politically charged writers have rather bizarrely started labeling it as liberal propaganda, but the politically motivated out there are always looking for a reason to stir up red state versus blue state controversy."
I'm not that farmiliar with it; but I wasn't aware the village voice was any kind of conservative media outlet.
Fair enough I'm sure there are lots of reviews out there at the time though I read your review there was one only review I had seen up on Rottentomatoes that complained about it being preachy concerning the enviroment and that review was from the Village Voice.
Brilliant review. Although, I think most critics have noticed the environmentalist punch at the end, I don't think the target audience (parents and their kids) will mind it.
I love your reference to Lord of the Rings. I'm glad my family wasn't the only ones who saw the Misty Mountians (and Frodo!) in Antartica.
My dad and i are true republicans. I just heard reviews from other people, and I'm starting to not want to see this movie. Although I think the penguins in here are very cute, they might not be as sweet as what you may think. My final opinion is no child under 8 should see this movie. I've heard it has some very graphic and violent seens, that does not please me.
Lol. Wow this is very said. I have wanted to see this movie sense June. Just before the file was released on Nov 17th I hard heard about its agenda. While I think that it may not be the best movie to use for the agenda I still think it was good. After seeing the file I Googled “Happy Feet Controversy” only to find these random idiotic reviews. Yes it was in fact a kids movie, but maybe Hollywood feels that sense adult are to ignorance to the obvious that it may help to target kid so that there may be a future for other species on the earth besides humans. I read on one reviews that a mom decided to take her kids to the zoo instead of seeing the movie. Yes because that penguins at the zoo love being there so much. I found that to be so sad that she wants to harbor her kids from seeing this movie for a reason that is the truth. I did not like the movie as much as much as I hoped to but it was not that bad.
If anyone has seen March of The Penguins then you know that there is a shortage of fish in areas where Penguins live…. And what happened after the movie. They stopped finishing in those areas.
Face it HollyWood it probably the strongest weapon that people have to get a message across. So to get that message out there Mom and dads drive there gas hogging SUVs to the movie and stop on at McDonals on the way to help there kids become more obease and the spend 50-75 bucks at the theater to watch this movies and then get mad that there’s a message. I’m not a environmentalist or a Liberal or a Republican or a Democrat. I my self am studying to become a film director. The fact of the matter is the message came form logic. People get mad when someone trys to tell them something they don’t want to hear. So holly wood put it right inform of there faces. But this is America more and more messages will come and more people will be the sophisticated human beings we so called are and try to argue against fact with ridiculess accusations. It’s a sad world and country we all live in. But people feen off drama and to talk about thing they can not control. Sooner or later parent cant harbor there kids form this stuff. Why do you think messages are in movies or thing that kids enjoy, they are the only hope for the future?
Oh my lord-Ryan Wolf really has to learn how to type, or at least proofread before submitting an entry...but that doesn't take away from that fact that he's right on most of his points.
aaand Nikki's a frikkin moron. No offense or anything (heh), but how can you start off by saying that you haven't seen the movie and then go on to make a recommendation about who should or should not see this movie?? You're not pleased by what you've heard? Why don't you watch the frikkin movie and make an educated opinion about it?
Hollywood Liberals are trying to win over kids now? How desperate they have become. Oh....and the movie sucks....definitly not the best from Robin Williams
I just got an email from a Christian standpoint speaking against Happy Feet. I got so interested on this email because I watched it with my kids a few months after its release. It was masterfully done, great over all message and talk about animation - top notch!!! I take the over-all message as "have dominion over the earth" as a divine mandate seen all over this film. Some Christian critics however (like this email), saw it as an attack against churches. They say Mummbles was the sinner and outcast while the institutionalized penguins are the churches. Of course, following this line of thought, the church comes to be wrong at the very end. WAY TOO MUCH, I say!!! After receiving this email, I typed in "happy feet controversy" and sure enough, I grinned of the fact that many have taken sides and saw offense left and right. I just say it's hard to please everyone. Josh, you wrote well to advice all readers to not "go looking for it." I say, just enjoy the movie and get the big picture. And Christians, I'm not an environmentalist guru, nor a political individual, but I'd sure love to see God's green earth still flourishing by the time my children reach 20. Thanks for having my 2 cents added in.
Actually, I got the quite opposite perception (being a Christian). I perceived the institutionalized penguins as the jews in the old testament. The "elders" were the pharisees, saducees, etc. and Mumble would be like the "Christ" - being rejected. He then leaves, but only temporarily. The little penguins (which include Ramon) would be the disciples. While Mumble was in the zoo, his "vision" was in still inline with my interpretation. In this "vision" the little penguins (the disciples) told Mumble that they have kept believing in him and that they have not lost hope. They then ask Mumble, "You're coming back, right?" So how's that as a parallel to His second coming?
He then succeeds on returning, bringing "salvation" to the rest of the penguins. And when he goes back, he succeeds in influencing the rest of the penguins to accept him and his dancing (his ways - his gospel).
Anyway, that's just me. We all have our own way of looking at it.
WOW!!!!!!!!Such a wonderful movie i have never even seen before !!!!
I went to see this fabulus movie with my family and enjoyed a very lot......the most important thing was that script was new and the best.. I thanks the director for giving us such an entertaiment...................
Happy Feet is...stunning. I only just got around to seeing it.Perhaps the best animated feature ever made. Certainly the most courageous. You're absolutely right Josh. If you see anything sinister in it it's because you're looking for it. Stop re- creating it in your own image and just...enjoy.
i think happy feet is a wonderfull colabaeration of values and attitudes that are being presented toward environmental change and over fishing and our detremental effect on the environment and happy bright music along with a killer plot.
i hope they make a happy feet 2 and focus on the problem with global warming.
This site is operated by Cinema Blend LLC. For advertising inquiries, contact Gorilla Nation. CinemaBlend.com is a private, independently owned website which is intended only as entertainment. The views expressed on this website may or may not reflect those of its owner. Don't take us too seriously.
November 15th, 2006 at 13:45
"A few early reviews from more politically charged writers have rather bizarrely started labeling it as liberal propaganda, but the politically motivated out there are always looking for a reason to stir up red state versus blue state controversy."
I'm not that farmiliar with it; but I wasn't aware the village voice was any kind of conservative media outlet.