Starring: Brandon Routh (Superman/Clark Kent), Kevin Spacey (Lex Luthor), Kate Bosworth (Lois Lane), Eva Marie Saint (Ma Kent), Frank Langella (Perry White), Sam Huntington (Jimmy Olsen), Noel Niell, James Marsden (Richard White), Stephan Bender (Young Clark), Kal Penn, Parker Posey
When the opening credits blast across the screen in Superman Returns using the same time honored whooshing style made famous by Richard Donner back in 1978, it's a giddy moment; alive and filled with the sheer power of the Man of Steel. When Bryan Singer's name flies across the picture with his directed by credit, you get the sense that seeing his name there, that way, is something he's been waiting for all his life. What kid wouldn't want their names swooping across the screen in a Superman movie? Forget Scorsese or Spielberg, when you're a kid you want to be Richard Donner. On screen his name had more flair.
Others have tried, but Bryan Singer has truly captured exactly what a Superman movie is supposed to be. Gone is even the smallest vestige of camp or tongue-in-cheek, in its place is a smart story about thinking, feeling people. One of those people just happens to be a god. Godlike is exactly what Superman is in this film, in a way he's never been before. He's Atlas, carrying the world on his shoulders. He's almighty Zeus, hurling thunderbolts at antlike mortal men. Kevin Spacey's Lex Luthor compares his fight with Superman to the ancient story of Prometheus, and when he does so it's not just a parable, he means it. So does Superman Returns.
But how do audiences identify with a god? How can we root for someone almost completely free of human weaknesses or foibles? There's one thing both mortals and immortals have in common: Even gods fall in love. For Superman love is Lois Lane, and when he returns after an absence of 5 years he finds that love no longer requited. While Kal-El was off chasing remnants of Krypton, Lois Lane has moved on. She's got a man, a kid, a new life. Now that he's back, where does Superman fit in? Is he just a forgotten memory, or is Lois Lane still secretly in love?
As the movie develops it takes on almost a lyrical quality. It's at first bittersweet and filled with longing, but by the end Superman Returns is an uplifting experience punctuated by unexpected meaning and depth. This isn't Spider-Man, and Superman will never be a troubled everyman. Superman stands for something big. He's almost a force of nature. He's hope in the face of utter despair. He's more of a symbol than a man, yet Singer finds soul within Superman's "S". Superman's nigh invulnerable, but he's not invincible.
Perhaps most importantly to hardcore fans, Superman Returns retains all the earnest energy of the first two Donner movies. In making his version, Singer chose to ignore the two bad Superman movies (Superman III and IV) and make his a sequel (at least in spirit) to Richard Donner's masterful Superman: The Movie and Superman II. His film is a loving tribute to those movies, and it's not just some gimmick. It goes further than a simple reuse of the beautiful, classic Superman score by John Williams or a gorgeous new version of the old flying Superman credits. There's a genuine affinity for the work that came before it, and from the pic's familiar opening through its closing dedication to Christopher and Dana Reeve it pays reverent homage. That's nice, but Superman Returns is a better film than any of its predecessors.
Singer builds his film around the awkwardly resumed relationship between Superman and Lois, then fills in the gaps with heady, character-driven action sequences cooked up by the maniacal Lex Luthor. It works because Returns' actors are nearly as brilliant as its script, each incorporating pieces of what previous actors did with the characters while putting their own stamp on it.
Brandon Routh is stellar as Superman and his Clark Kent, believe it or not, may be actually better than Christopher Reeve's. There's been a lot of concern that Routh's not physically imposing enough to pull off the role, that he's too slight of build. With good reason. If you're judging him from the trailers or US Magazine tabloid photos, he's not exactly a bulky guy. In the context of the film, that doesn't matter. Singer makes him look not just imposing and powerful, but super-human. A lot of the credit for that should go to Routh. Brandon's gotten himself into phenomenal shape, and he carries himself with all the confidence and poise you'd expect from a man of might. He's John Henry driving steel, he's Hercules knocking down giants with one mighty blow of his fist
If there's one thing that's really had people worried about Superman Returns, it's Kate Bosworth as Lois. She's not exactly a natural as the fearless reporter type. Had Kate been asked to play the Lois Lane of Superman: The Movie or Superman II she'd have failed. Instead she succeeds brilliantly here, because she's playing Lois at a different stage in her life. Margot Kidder's Lois is young, brash, and take-charge. Now older and a little wiser, Kate is what Kidder's Lois would be if she'd won her Pulitzer, achieved her career goals, and then settled down. That younger, always in trouble Lois is still in there; but she's learned a thing or two too since last we saw her in Superman II. As this Lois, Kate Bosworth is an unqualified success.
Kevin Spacey has joked that he based his Lex Luthor on an Enron executive, and that may not be far off the mark. To me though, his Lex seems more like a mix of Gene Hackman's great performance in Donner's movies and a lot of full on Kevin Spacey. As much as I love Hackman's energetic Lex Luthor, Spacey surpasses him and gives what is probably the best performance in any Superman film. He's not just villainous or quick witted; he's poignant and even a little wise. He's also determined. This Lex doesn't preen while Superman rips down his lair. If Superman is an immovable force, then Lex Luthor is an unstoppable lever. Hackman's Lex was entertaining and while Spacey's is funny, he's also downright scary.
What's best about Superman Returns is that it's a deeply personal story with global significance. Superman is searching for something in the universe. He abandons Earth to go looking for it, and finds only a graveyard instead. When he returns the things he thought he had to come home to have been turned upside down, and he's left still looking for whatever it is that he's missing. Carried by a maelstrom of soul searching emotional turmoil, the Man of Steel is back with all the passion and heartfelt power that American cinema can muster. Bryan blends his beautiful vision with an elegant, intimate story and the result is a work of real art. By the end of the film Superman has found what he's missing, and like his return to cinemas, it was worth the wait. Now that it's here, Superman Returns deserves to be seen again, and again, and again.
Note: This website is not intended for use by minors. The views expressed in this comments section are not necessarily our own. Comments that we deem to be poorly worded, off topic, or threatening will not be published. For free, uncensored discussion visit our forum.
Excellent as always Josh. This is why Cinema Blend remains my pimary site for movie reviews. Concise, honest, and polished. I had my reservations, but seeing as Singer has a nearly flawless resume I'm trying to figure out why I ever doubted him. thanks again.
Loved the review. I read it on Friday and was lucky enough to watch the movie tonight at work as it came in around 3pm on Sunday afternoon. It was like being a child and waking up on Christmas morning. The package also contained the teaser for Spiderman 3 which showed more than any other Spiderman teasers have ever shown. I agree that Routh may very well be better. I never had doubts on the movie after Singer took over; but I also never expected it to exceed my expectations. Especially when they were held high with all the teasers and trailers that started rolling out. Once again...I loved the review you gave and it does live up to how well the movie is.
I broke out the first two Donner Superman DVDs and re-watched them over the weekend just to get myself in the groove. I even have the soundtrack on my iPod! All of that plus this wonderful review of yours makes me sure of just one thing:
I need to see this. I need to see this NOW. It sounds like everything I've been waiting for.
Please tell me this movie is not filled with morons who can't tell the difference between clark kent with glasses and clark kent without... that alone is what made the previous movies a joke and will in turn help to destroy this one in my eyes.
asd, I'm sorry but those things are all integral to a Superman movie. If you can't accept them, then you have no busy seeing it. I'm not sure why you even need to ask.
asd, you're talking about a film where the main character comes from another planet. . .can fly. . .bend steel (or titanium or really really hard plastic) in his bare hands. . .bullets bounce off of him. . .but the glasses thing is what stops you??
I asked because I figured they'd try to bring a more realistic approach to the franchise and abandon the absurd ways of the previous ones. (Kind've like the path Batman Begins took) I'm not quite sure why you questioned my question quite honestly for there was nothing wrong with it. If I walked up to my friends, co-workers, and especially my girlfriend I'd expect them to recognize me with glasses or not (as anyone should). Maybe this is just another power he has that I'm not aware of, one that when he takes off his glasses and transforms into superman he also emits something that makes everyone dumb and blind around him.
How dare you have an opinion of this movie/hero other than eternal love - and then go as far to express that opinion. For shame! You should really expand your suspension of disbelief. I suggest you expand them so much, in fact, that you begin to believe that crap movies are awesome, and that you would lay down your life for a single glimpse of the shiniest C.G. your eyes have ever seen.
Anyone who has negative opinions of this movie should not be permitted to see it. We should be unified under one binding opinion.
Sarcasm should require some form of formal training and licencing. At least then it'd only be those who were any good at it who were allowed to use it.
Stuart, your reply was weak... try again. I love fantasy movies just as much as the next person, but what I don't want is stupidity. Not being able to tell the difference between a man with glasses and the very same man without is not fantasy, just retarded.
...but I'm not complaining about those things (although his suit is gay) I'm complaining about something that is OBVIOUS. Lois Lane, a woman who fell in love with Superman, never knew she worked with this very same man until he told her?! How's that even possible?
And something else since all you can do with the first issue is "beat around the bush." I've read another review that says where Superman went or why he even left was never answered... Is this true? I would think that they would've provided SOME story and maybe a few scenes showing Superman visiting other unknown territory or something.
I'm just trying to decide if this movie should be placed in my "theater list" or "download list", so that's why I'm asking :)
I'm pretty sure it was from IGN's review... I forget now. But I'm glad to see it's wrong, for I am really interested in knowing where and why he left... So okay, movie is back onto my "theater" list, hehe. Hopefully I can go see it within the next day or two.
Great review Josh. I watched the two superman movies again (for the millionth time) before watching it this morning. I loved the fact that the achnowledge C & D Reeves. Especially at the end of the movie where he does his flight. I wish they had gone more into where he had gone for 5 years. He just mentions is in one sentence and that's it. I can't wait to see the sequel (hopefully).
i luv superman! he flies, he's super strong and has lazer eyes. it's the best movie i've ever seen. and, this is the best review i've ever seen. josh is very right. i don't like the negative reviews. i like reviews from fans. i loved the moovie before i saw it. now it's true!
Thanks for your kind words Ken. But to clarify I'm not a Superman "fan" except in that I'm a fan of good movies.
I've never read more than one or two of the comics, and while I like the first two Donner movies they certainly wouldn't rank as all time favorites of mine. That's about the extent of my Superman fandom before this movie.
We must have seen different movies. Just one scene alone shows what a monumental disappointment this was. Superman doesn't even notice he's standing on an island made of kryptonite. Yet he is so weakened by it that common street thugs almost beat him to death. In spite of this, a fall of 1000 feet - from that height, hitting even water is like hitting concrete - doesn't turn him into paste? Even with a kryptonite chunk in his side? People in the audience were going "What the *&$%#???" at this and lots of other badly written scenes and characterizations (Lex is supposed to be an inventive, criminal mastermind yet the best he keeps coming up with are real estate deals?!). This from the same guy who gave us the terrific X-MEN and X-MEN 2 films? I far preferred BATMAN BEGINS and I'm not even a Batman fan!
There are some questions I have that maybe some of you can answer if you don't mind.
Lois shouldn't know anything about her sexual romp with the man of steel, right?
Woudn't this make her angry for being essentially raped by Superman?
If Lois was so hung up on Superman she certainly didn't waste time finding a new man right after Sups left. And she obviously didn't have a problem doing the humpty with him if he thinks he's the dad. Doesn't this make Lois seem kind of easy? This was the whole problem I had with Superman II. Having him sleep with her opened up a whole can of unwanted worms.
Is it just me or was the gang up on Superman a little extreme? Yes I know this is the age of the PG-13 movie and that audiences like dark, dark, dark, but man this is Superman. I can't even take my girls to see this movie because of the beating Sups takes in the end. Shouldn't Superman be a movie for all ages?
Why did they make Perry White so unlikable? If I were Superman I would of left the daily planet globe paste him.
Just to let everyone know, I liked the movie. It was well done and I am certainly glad to see the big guy back. Cheerio Everyone.
I too was disappointed by this film. Maybe I expected god-like ferocity throughout and wasn't looking for an emotional relationship flick. Where to begin... maybe I should have refreshed myself with the older movies first. I was dissapointed that the boy didn't play a more significant roll. Non climatic.... I guess everyone sets up for sequels these days. I went with my husband for a prescreen date before we take the kids. I think my 10 year old son would be bored to death. Too much!
finally saw Superman and must say it was better than I expected, especially once the stupidity that plagues every superman was pushed aside. The only downside if anything was the length and lack of action.
Also I still wish they would've done more regarding where he was. He was gone for five freaking years and all he said was that he found nothing... I wanted at least some clips of him in other places, maybe discovering new planets and stuff. SOMETHING!!
Ok, heres the deal with the 5 years. It took him 2.5 to get to the remains of Krypton and 2.5 to get back. If you read the novelization it is dealt with in greater detail.
Scenes that explained more were cut for length, but were filmed (as were more scenes with Stephan Bender) and will hopefully show up as an extended version or deleted scenes.
Superman is a fantasy, and the dual role of CK/Supe is a part of the Superman lore.
Without it, it would not be Superman.
This site is operated by Cinema Blend LLC. For advertising inquiries, contact Gorilla Nation. CinemaBlend.com is a private, independently owned website which is intended only as entertainment. The views expressed on this website may or may not reflect those of its owner. Don't take us too seriously.
June 24th, 2006 at 18:12
One of the best reviews of this movie I've read. Thanks. Look forward to the movie more because of a review like this.