This year’s Oscar nominations have become a major topic of controversy as, for the second year in a row, every nominee in an acting category was white. The criticism of this year's selections has been strong, and there have even been calls to boycott the awards from some corners of Hollywood. Now, some members of the Academy of Motion Picture Arts & Sciences are speaking out and while some are admitting there may be some problems with the process as a whole, individuals are insisting that racism is not part of it.
While no black actors or actresses were nominated for Oscars this year a number of individual members have come forward to say that they did vote to nominate people of color and that those people simply did not get enough votes because the number of great performances was incredibly high. Actresses Penelope Ann Miller was one Academy member who spoke to The Hollywood Reporter to say that she tried to nominate black performers and she doesn’t appreciate being called racist because they didn’t make the short list.
Her comments were echoed by another Academy member who felt that everybody was being painted with the same brush. While this member asked to remain anonymous, it’s clear that whoever they are, they don’t like the implication that racism was involved in their vote.
Of course, the problem is that unless every member of the Academy comes forward and shows their hand, which won’t happen, it’s impossible to know what the voting actually looked like. Were there black actors who very nearly made the cut, or was Penelope Ann Miller's nomination one of the few?
John Ridley, the screenwriter behind 12 Years A Slave, probably has the most realistic take on the situation. He figures most Academy members just never saw Beasts of No Nation, and that has more to do with demographics than overt racism.
It’s true that there were many actors, as well as directors, of different races who are worthy of nominations that did not receive them. At the same time, if great movies lost out on nominations because the older, and admittedly mostly white, members of the organization didn’t bother to see them, or simply didn’t "get" them, then that does seem like a missed opportunity.
CinemaBlend’s resident theme park junkie and amateur Disney historian. Armchair Imagineer. Epcot Stan. Future Club 33 Member.
Your Daily Blend of Entertainment News
Thank you for signing up to CinemaBlend. You will receive a verification email shortly.
There was a problem. Please refresh the page and try again.