Leave a Comment
Believe it or not, Logan is not a perfect movie. Hugh Jackman's final outing as Wolverine is a fantastic X-Men story, but that doesn't make it flawless. With that in mind, a new video has surfaced showing exactly where Logan falters in its storytelling, and it really leaves no stone unturned. Check out the video below to see for yourself.
Now that we have all had the opportunity to sit through that video from CinemaSins, let's unpack what we saw. Yes, despite the fact that it's arguably one of the best superhero movies of the last few years (if not of all time), Logan has a few problems with cliches, logic gaps and glaring plot holes. There are the seemingly minor issues, such as the fact that Logan somehow manages to put on a white shirt after a battle without any of the blood seeping into it. There are the somewhat odd moments, like The Reavers never shooting the tires out on Wolverine's limo as he makes his escape with Laura and Professor X. Then, finally, there are the downright flawed moments -- such as the ultimate (and somewhat polarizing) reveal of X-24 in the Munson house around the film's midpoint. All in all, this video paints a picture of a movie that (even with its incredible strengths) has flaws that are worth pointing out in the name of proper film criticism.
Having said that, we need to take this time to juxtapose the issues pointed out in this video with the glaring plot holes exposed in other comic book movies. Logan has flaws, but James Mangold still managed to craft one of the most tightly orchestrated and heartwrenching superhero movies ever committed to film. When compared to films like X-Men: Apocalypse or Batman V Superman: Dawn of Justice, it's a bonafide work of art. In fact, the movie is so good that Wade Wilson himself even recently participated in a Screen Junkies Honest Trailer to sing Logan's praises. Do you have any idea how rare it is for Deadpool's main character to talk about something related to Wolverine with a positive spin? That's how you know Logan is a good movie.
At the end of the day, even with its handful of flaws, Logan is still a watershed moment in the history of comic book movies. As the final X-Men movie to feature Hugh Jackman as the clawed mutant badass, the film effectively closes a prosperous chapter of 20th Century Fox Marvel history. With the Wolverine character now retired for the foreseeable future, we will see many significant changes take place within the next few years. Specifically, it has even been rumored that Dafne Keene's X-23 may get a solo movie of her own at some point. Hugh Jackman may be gone, but it's clear that he left this universe on a solid note and in good hands.