The Basic Gist Of The Controversy:
Variant covers are nothing new to the comic book industry. They’re usually another interpretation of the story found inside the issue, and also an opportunity for the book to drive a sort of collectibility. This year marks the 75th anniversary DC’s most iconic villain and in June, the comic book company looks to celebrate The Joker with a collection of variant covers. So when Albuquerque payed homage to Alan Moore’s famed story, it was a very particular Joker that has upset many fans. The cover that Albuquerque created was questionable, but the controversy lies more in the inspiration behind it.
In Alan Moore and Brian Bolland’s Batman: The Killing Joke, Barbara Gordon aka Batgirl was shot and paralyzed by the Joker. Within the storyline, after the Joker shoots and paralyzes Barbara he strips her naked and takes photographs to drive her father (Commissioner Gordon) mad. It is common interpretation that Barbara was sexually assaulted in this progression, though Moore has denied that intention. Paying homage to this specific storyline (which Moore himself has tried to distance himself from) isn’t the entire gist of the controversy though. The bigger issue many are having is that this variant is highlighting a much darker time in the character’s history, which is the complete opposite direction that the current co-writing team of Cameron Stewart and Brenden Fletcher along with artist Babs Tarr have been producing.
Why Some Want It Pulled:
Many feel this cover to be a digression from the current state of the female heroine whose new storyline is a more optimistic direction with a fresh take on the role of female superheroes who are often overtly sexualized and marginalized. Also, the connection to the questionable Moore storyline has many in uproar that the cover holds unwanted sexual subtext with the Joker holding Batgirl against her will. In response to the violent cover, Twitter users began using the hashtag “#changethecover”, which has been trending since the release on Friday. Many argued that the cover was isolating and inconsistent saying the new series had worked hard to draw more female readers, and this was completely offensive. Even the writers on ‘Team Batgirl’ spoke out about the cover, saying they had not seen or approved it whatsoever, and it went against their intentions with the story.
The cover was not seen or approved by anyone on Team Batgirl and was completely at odds with what we are doing with the comic.— Cameron Stewart (@cameronMstewart) March 17, 2015
Why Some Want It To Remain:
Others found DC’s quick pull of the cover a hinderance on freedom of expression and censorship. And stood by the fact that the controversy existed because of a very small majority of easily offended people. Those who wanted the comic to remain believed that the Joker is a threatening character, and this cover is not nearly as violent as some of the other moments he’s partaken in. Some were even so upset about the pull that they started a online petition entitled “Save The Batgirl Joker Variant. Save Your Freedom of Choice!” which now has a total 294 signatures.
The Final Outcome:
The final decision to pull the cover was actually first made by the artist himself, Rafael Albuquerque, who asked DC not to publish his Batgirl variant cover. In his own statement (via CBR) he explained that he intended to play homage to the Alan Moore comic that he feels is an important part of Batgirl’s canon, and could not avoid portraying the traumatic relationship. But for his art to hurt and upset people, that’s where he drew the line. He explained:
For me, it was just a creepy cover that brought up something from the character’s past that I was able to interpret artistically. But it has become clear, that for others, it touched a very important nerve. I respect these opinions and, despite whether the discussion is right or wrong, no opinion should be discredited.
My intention was never to hurt or upset anyone through my art. For that reason, I have recommended to DC that the variant cover be pulled.
DC Entertainment’s official statement on the subject honored Albuquerque’s wishes, and ultimately decided not to publish the variant at the author’s request. But, in their statement they also mentioned that “threats of violence and harassment are wrong and have no place in comics or society”. Albuquerque tweeted out about that statement, confirming that his decision was not based on any threats. To which Cameron Stewart, one of the writers of the current series responded:
Something to clarify, because DCs statement was a little unclear. @rafaalbuquerque did not get threats. People OBJECTING to the cover did.— Cameron Stewart (@cameronMstewart) March 17, 2015
No matter which side you may agree with in this controversial event, it is definitely not the last we’ll hear of it. As more questionable story themes, covers, newly created characters, and other elements of the expanding comic book industry are being introduced, they will be met with some sort of critique from disapproving parties. As for this Batgirl cover controversy, even if the cover isn’t going to run come June, the continuing conversation behind it will probably make it more widely seen than it would have been solely on the shelves.