How Council Of Dads Is Handling Its Big Death Differently Than This Is Us

council of dads tom everett scott nbc
(Image credit: NBC)

Spoilers ahead for the second episode of Council of Dads Season 1 on NBC, called "I'm Not Fine."

Council of Dads has officially returned to NBC with its second episode, airing more than a month after its original premiere following the Season 4 finale of This Is Us. Since Council of Dads' very first episode ended with the heartbreaking death of a father, comparisons to This Is Us and the death of Jack Pearson were inevitable. Of course, This Is Us has brought Milo Ventimiglia back many times despite Jack's death, whereas the second episode of Council of Dads didn't feature much new footage of Tom Everett Scott's Scott. So, how will the two NBC family dramas compare, especially with such a big death early on?

Showrunner Tony Phelan chatted with CinemaBlend about how Council of Dads is handling the big death differently than This Is Us. When asked if Tom Everett Scott will reprise his role as Scott despite Scott's death at the end of the series premiere, Phelan said this:

Of course he will! I mean, my God! [laughs] The other thing that we were very insistent on from the beginning is, this is a show about moving forward, not necessarily a show about flashbacks, which differentiates it from This Is Us. But with that in mind, Scott comes back a couple times this season in I think really interesting and creative ways.

While fans haven't seen the last of Tom Everett Scott as Scott on Council of Dads, this isn't a situation like This Is Us spending so much time in the past via flashback. Notably, Tony Phelan (who previously served as co-showrunner of Grey's Anatomy) didn't rule out Scott's appearances coming via flashback, but simply said that this is a series about moving forward rather than always looking back. And hey, there are always dream sequences, hallucinations, and/or video recordings as possibilities, right?

Council of Dads will continue to get creative in how it handles time, even if not constantly jumping back and forth between past, present, and future. As viewers know, the series premiere tackled a year in the life of the family as Scott went from diagnosis to death within the span of an hour, but the second episode covered only days.

While enough time passed for Luly to make her decision not to move to New York and to meet her birth mom, JJ (and Oliver) learn how to ride a bike, and Anthony to drop the bombshell that he's Luly's biological dad, not nearly as much time was covered in "I'm Not Fine" vs. the premiere. Explaining why Council of Dads started with Scott's story before actually getting into the council, Tony Phelan said;

So that's where we came up with the idea of telling the story over the space of a year [in the premiere] and then the continuing show plays with time a lot. So there will be one episode that moves us from Halloween through New Year's, but then there are other episodes that take place over the course of the day. So yeah, I think that's what it was. We wanted everybody to get a sense of Scott, of what kind of dad he was, how important he was, and to really grapple with [the council] as Robin does. How are these guys gonna fill his role?

Council of Dads doesn't need flashbacks (or flash-forwards) to play with time, and viewers can look forward to an episode spanning several months at some point in the first season. Season 1 did finish filming before production halts across the television industry, so the story of the council of dads and the Perry family won't be cut short.

Even with Tom Everett Scott returning to Council of Dads and Scott's continued impact as his family moves forward, the show will of course continue to develop the characters who make up the council. Anthony isn't the only one with a lot to deal with when it comes to the Perry kids. Tony Phelan shared some details about what's to come:

Larry has this kind of great gruff relationship with Theo but at the same time some of the fun in later episodes is seeing him have to interact with JJ and you see these deep bonds that all develop over time. But at the same time, Robin appeals to Oliver because Theo is very moody and slamming doors and everything. And it turns out that Oliver played football in college and he gets Theo interested in football, which is a problem for Robin being a doctor with, you know, all of the signs of brain trauma. So you’ll see the dads in various combinations.

The ensemble of Council of Dads will continue to mix rather than just pair off, even if some ties are more natural than ever. Robin and Oliver were close friends before Scott died and appointed Oliver as one of the men to help his kids with "dad" stuff, whereas Larry seems determined to lend a hand wherever he can.

Larry may not always be the most tactful or delicate, but Theo has already responded to his brand of help, and JJ might not be able to ride a bike yet if not for Larry! That's not to say that the dads won't be dealing with issues of their own. Tony Phelan teased what's ahead:

And then you'll also see in the case of Oliver, who is married with a kid of his own, you'll see the challenge of trying to be on this council while at the same time having a marriage and having his own kid and having his husband say, 'You're spending all this time with their family. I don't want to be the guy jealous of the family whose father just died. You got to find a better way to balance this.' And we'll also see, we'll find out that Larry is estranged from his family because of his history of alcoholism. And being around these kids and dealing with them helps him in his quest to reach out to his family.

Fortunately, Council of Dads won't be going away any time soon. The first season received an order for ten episodes, so there is still plenty to come for the extended Perry family. Council of Dads moves to its regular time slot on Thursday, May 7 at 8 p.m. ET on NBC.

For some additional viewing options now and in the not-too-distant future, be sure to check out our 2020 spring premiere schedule and our 2020 summer premiere guide. Council of Dads is only one of several shows that managed to finish filming before production had to stop, so primetime isn't running out of content even if some of TV's biggest shows wrapped early.

Laura Hurley
Senior Content Producer

Laura turned a lifelong love of television into a valid reason to write and think about TV on a daily basis. She's not a doctor, lawyer, or detective, but watches a lot of them in primetime. CinemaBlend's resident expert and interviewer for One Chicago, the galaxy far, far away, and a variety of other primetime television. Will not time travel and can cite multiple TV shows to explain why. She does, however, want to believe that she can sneak references to The X-Files into daily conversation (and author bios).