Skip to main content

CBS' Big Brother Winners Want $2 Million Season Like Survivor: Winners At War

Big Brother 19 Paul vs Josh as Josh is announced as the winner

(Image credit: CBS)

Survivor just ended Season 39, the controversy-laden Island of the Idols, and did the usual promotion for the next season. Survivor: Winners at War has 20 past Survivor winners competing against each other for a prize twice as good as the usual money -- $2 million. It raised a lot of eyebrows and got CBS' Big Brother winners wondering when they'd ever get a prize even close to that.

Big Brother airs every summer -- and lately the seasons have stretched out for up to almost 100 days, way more than the standard 39 days of Survivor. The prize for winning Big Brother is $500,000. The Amazing Race pays $1 million to the winning team of two.

You can make arguments for why Survivor's prize is larger -- bigger ratings, for one thing. But it's also prestigious, as reality TV goes, since it's been airing since 2000 as one of the first and most popular competition shows. EW asked Survivor host Jeff Probst if there was any difficulty behind-the-scenes at CBS to double the prize from $1 million to $2 million:

That was a CBS decision and they never hesitated. They’ve been very supportive and excited about this season. They know what a milestone it is for Survivor to reach its 20th year and 40th season. We all want to celebrate! And I need to say it again, this season only happens because 20 former winners all said yes. We don’t have this season without them.

It really is an amazing milestone year for Survivor. Big Brother isn't quite hitting the same milestones in 2020. But the money was a CBS decision, eh? Hmm...

Big Brother fans and some players were already hoping the Big Brother 2020 season would feature returning all-stars. Now past winners are hoping for their own version of Winners At War with that $2 million prize.

Here's what Big Brother 16 winner Derrick Levasseur wrote, tagging host Julie Chen and the CBS account:

See more

BB16's Derrick is considered one of the best players of the game, so he would certainly be invited back for any winners season. He would also almost certainly be one of the first houseguests to be targeted for eviction. So unless he got more twists to help, he'd be in a tight spot. But it would be fascinating to watch.

Big Brother 19 winner Josh Martinez was more of a surprise winner against Paul Abrahamian in 2017, which would probably help keep him underestimated in an all-winners season. He has tweeted before about an all-stars season and he definitely sounds game to return for a $2 million winners season, if CBS gives them the chance:

See more

Survivor: Winners At War is Season 40, so the 20 players who'll return only mark half of the past winners. Here are the 20 castaways who'll compete:

• Adam KleinWinner of Survivor: Millennials vs. Gen X• Amber Brkich MarianoWinner of Survivor: All-Stars• Ben DriebergenWinner of Survivor: Heroes v Healers v Hustlers• Danni BoatwrightWinner of Survivor: Guatemala• Denise StapleyWinner of Survivor: Philippines• Ethan ZohnWinner of Survivor: Africa• Jeremy CollinsWinner of Survivor: Cambodia — Second Chance• Kim SpradlinWinner of Survivor: One World• Michele FitzgeraldWinner of Survivor: Kaoh Rong• Natalie AndersonWinner of Survivor: San Juan del Sur• Nick WilsonWinner of Survivor: David vs. Goliath• Parvati ShallowWinner of Survivor — Micronesia: Fans vs. Favorites• Boston Rob MarianoWinner of Survivor: Redemption Island• Sandra Diaz-TwineWinner of Survivor: Pearl Islands and Survivor: Heroes vs. Villains• Sarah LacinaWinner of Survivor: Game Changers• Sophie ClarkeWinner of Survivor: South Pacific• Tony VlachosWinner of Survivor: Cagayan• Tyson ApostolWinner of Survivor: Blood vs. Water• Wendell HollandWinner of Survivor: Ghost Island• Yul KwonWinner of Survivor: Cook Islands

Just going by the lineup, I feel like someone like Danni has a great shot to go far because she'll be underestimated. Survivor: Winners At War premieres February 12, 2020 on CBS. Big Brother 22 will air this summer. Apparently Celebrity Big Brother is skipping 2020 but host Julie Chen has been teasing something.

Do you hope CBS does go for a Big Brother: Winners At War season? Do they have enough players for that? It wouldn't have to be 20. Could be 15 or 16 from the 21 seasons to date. Here are 10 of the most memorable winners, so they'd just have to contact five or six more and hope they all agreed to return. I'm ready!

This poll is no longer available.

Gina grew up in Massachusetts and California in her own version of The Parent Trap. She went to three different middle schools, four high schools, and three universities -- including half a year in Perth, Western Australia. She currently lives in a small town in Maine, the kind Stephen King regularly sets terrible things in, so this may be the last you hear from her.