Sophia Bush has had a fascinating career thus far. She’s done a lot since her John Tucker Must Die days and plenty since her Chicago P.D exit (which may be one of the most controversial exits of the past decade.) Now she’s been in a steady stream of movies and television projects. In 2025, Bush stars in The Stranger in My Home. It’s an adaptation of Adele Parks’ book of the same name.
It follows a family whose life turns upside down when a stranger delivers the news of a baby switch, and things just continue to escalate into a thrilling conclusion. The Stranger in My Home reminds me a lot of Lifetime movies. As someone who used to watch them regularly, that made me enjoy this soapy, kind of campy, movie even more.
The Stranger In My Home Feels Over The Top In The Same Way My Favorite Lifetime Movies Do
If you watch enough Lifetime movies, you notice a pattern in many of them. It’s a story that starts fairly straightforward, with a nice American family, then someone enters the picture who changes everything. Those films usually continuously escalate into very ridiculous situations. These calm cinematic masterpieces often become intense thrillers. That usually means a fight scene of some sort between the heroine and the main antagonist.
The Stranger in My Home fits this pattern. It starts with Ali (Sophia Bush) discovering that her daughter Katie (Amiah Miller) was switched at birth with another family’s daughter. This forces these families to engage and integrate. It’s not an easy transition. Additionally, single father Tom (Chris Carmack) seems to have eyes for Ali, despite her husband still being around.
To not spoil the movie, I will simply say it goes very over the top and melodramatic by the end. If you love Lifetime movies, you specifically understands these types of films. It’s a distinct movie and genre, and while it's currently available on demand, I hope Lifetime seizes the opportunity and buys the licensing to stream or air it.
The title alone gives off a very Lifetime Saturday movie event vibe.
I Like That The Film Has So Many Predictable Twists
This isn’t going to win any awards for the best plot twists in movies. It has a ton of them, but, if you watch enough Lifetime movies, you can guess at least a few of surprises, as the film also makes them fairly easy to predict.
However, one of the main plots involving Ali you don’t figure out until later, because you aren’t given this information until further in.
The whole premise of this film is basically a plot twist for all these characters. Two children switched at birth isn’t something that happens much in real life or fiction, but the movie has at least four major twists and a few minor ones.
Some may say that’s too many in a single story, but I think that just adds to the film’s campy charm. It throws everything into this plot. That’s also what happens in many great Lifetime movies. The twists keep on coming and have varying degrees of ridiculousness.
I am someone who enjoys figuring out a twist before the reveal happens. Therefore, I had a really good time guessing all of them. I think they were pretty easy, but someone who doesn’t care to figure them out may see these moments as jaw dropping. Whether you figure out the twists early or see them as they happen, you’re still going to be entertained by them.
This especially applies to Lifetime movie fans. These movies and The Stranger in My Home know that a good melodrama needs at least three twists.
I Love That It’s Female-Driven Like All Lifetime Movies
Lifetime prides itself on being a network that has a female target audience. These movies are made with women in mind; made for and about them. So, most of Lifetime’s movies (if not all) are female-driven.
Sophia Bush very much leads and stars in The Stranger in My Home. She is the biggest name attached to it and the one who brings the most to the story. The other actors are also great, and Grey's Anatomy star Chris Carmack has an interesting character with plenty of secrets.
Amiah Miller is also compelling as Katie, one of the daughters dealing with this major, life-altering discovery. Katie and Ali are the ones most affected by this news. I wouldn’t say it's is one of Sophia Bush’s best projects, but it’s a decent movie platform for the One Tree Hill actress.
It reminds us of her on-screen charm, and why she should lead more movies. It’s also a reminder that female-led campy thrillers are the best kind of thrillers.
I Enjoy That The Stranger In My Home Tries To Be A Bit More Scandalous Than Most Lifetime Movies
Most Lifetime movies have some violence, sex, and maybe a bit of light profanity. However, most of the network's movies aren’t that sexually explicit, there is very little profanity, and the violence is almost at a cartoon level (at least the over-the-top violent scenes).
I think that’s the major thing that separates The Stranger in My Home from a Lifetime movie. It’s not made for TV or a certain audience, so it’s allowed to push some boundaries. However, it doesn’t go too explicit or use profanity. It’s still fairly suitable for older teens and above.
Nevertheless, I enjoy that the movie is a bit more bold with its content.
It’s A Serious Movie That Doesn’t Take Itself Too Seriously, And I Think That’s The Essence Of A Good Lifetime Movie
Some Lifetime movies are based on true stories and should be taken seriously. A few are even some of the best movies based on real events. But, a lot of them are fictional or very sensationalized versions of true events. These stories go so far away from realistic that they become almost comical.
I don’t think The Stranger in My Home production team intended to make this movie campy, but the result remains the same. This makes me believe at least some of the ridiculousness is intentional.
The writers, actors, and director helped play into the ridiculous storylines. I think part of the movie’s charm is that it is having fun and not trying to be an overly serious thriller.
You must confirm your public display name before commenting
Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.