Crystal Lake Creator Admits The Show Is Different From Friday The 13th In A Key Way, But His Explanation Still Has Me Pumped

Jason in Friday the 13th Part V
(Image credit: Paramount)

Even as a longtime fan of horror movies, and a Friday the 13th series apologist (which is practically its own personality type) I’ll admit that when the Voorhees family was announced as the center of a prestige TV project, I wasn’t sure what to make of it. A slasher story stretched across serialized episodes? And when the studio started teasing its newly minted "Jason Universe" with multi-project plans, I found myself even more confused. That’s a lot of runway for a franchise that once gave us a guy in a hockey mask punching heads off on a boat. But the creator of the upcoming Crystal Lake series admits the show is different from Friday the 13th in a key way, and his explanation still has me excited and ready to sign up for a Peacock subscription.

The team behind Crystal Lake is finally talking, and the pitch is starting to make sense. In a new interview with Entertainment Weekly, showrunner Brad Caleb Kane, who also helped build HBO’s It: Welcome to Derry, explained that the series isn’t actually trying to mimic the original films beat for beat. Instead, it’s reshaping the world around a tone that predates Jason’s hockey mask era entirely. As he told the outlet:

In many ways, it's a psychological thriller. It's a paranoid '70s thriller. It has all of the DNA of a slasher without quite being a slasher. There are rivers of blood in the show. There are very, I think, ingenious kill sequences and deaths and murders, but it's all done in service of character and theme and place and time.

That framing of psychological tension first and slasher brutality second is not what I expected, but it might be precisely what the franchise needs. Kane says he approached the show by examining the cultural moment that gave rise to the original 1980 film: a post-’70s America defined by mistrust of institutions, second-wave feminism, and a broader sense of national paranoia. The idea isn’t just to recreate Camp Crystal Lake, but to reconstruct the world that shaped Pamela Voorhees long before she picked up a knife.

Linda Cardellini as Margo in No Good Deed.

(Image credit: Netflix)

And speaking of Pamela, Linda Cardellini is stepping into the role. According to Kane, she’ll surprise a lot of people. If you only know her for her comedic or dramatic work in Dead to Me, ER, or Brokeback Mountain, he suggests this performance hits an entirely different gear. He wouldn’t say more, but the way he talked about her had me practically whispering “ki-ki-ki, ma-ma-ma” under my breath.

The show also introduces young Jason (played by Callum Vinson), years before he becomes the franchise’s silent mascot. Rather than retread the continuity battles of the films, where Jason is first dead, then alive, then undead, then… whatever was happening in Jason X, the prequel series seems more interested in the knotty family dynamics that started it all. The supporting cast rounds things out nicely, with William Catlett, Devin Kessler, Cameron Scoggins, and newcomer Gwendolyn Sundstrom joining the mix.

More than anything, the show’s creator sounds committed to making Crystal Lake feel like its own thing. Yes, fans will get blood. Yes, there will be kills worth talking about. But the engines here seem to be mood, era, and character — the stuff the movies never had the time or structure to explore. For my money that's exciting, because it gives this series a reason to exist beyond IP recognition.

I may have started out skeptical, but Kane’s explanation has me more than ready to see where this goes. If the series can blend ’70s paranoia cinema with slasher movie energy and give Pamela Voorhees the kind of character study she’s never gotten, Crystal Lake could sit alongside shows like Bates Motel and Hannibal, as the rare prequels deepen a horror icon instead of flattening them.

Ryan graduated from Missouri State University with a BA in English/Creative Writing. An expert in all things horror, Ryan enjoys covering a wide variety of topics. He's also a lifelong comic book fan and an avid watcher of Game of Thrones and House of the Dragon. 

You must confirm your public display name before commenting

Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.